Commuting will not cost you an extra $250 in any world I know of. You are typically only moving a biking distance here.
Note that it doesn't need to you personally that moves. Even people who would move anyway will force lower rents just to attract new renters. It takes longer this way but renters typically search a large area when looking for a new place and they care about their costs vs ammentities.
What if moving costs $1000, which is another $83 per month over a year.