Re:One Genius' Lonely Crusade to Teach a Computer Common Sense
by arethuza on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @10:12AM
(#41788194)
That argument sounds awfully like Drew McDermott's A Critique of Pure Reason from 1987 which was one of the things that made me get out of the "good old fashioned" AI world in the mid 1990s.
Re:One Genius' Lonely Crusade to Teach a Computer Common Sense
by gbasin on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @08:39AM
(#41787258)
this was my main takeaway from 20th century philosophy lol
Re:One Genius' Lonely Crusade to Teach a Computer Common Sense
by freilanzer on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @09:00AM
(#41787475)
> The fundamental flaw with Lenat's approach is that humans do not think with first order predicate calculus. We do not juggle a bunch of statements/rules the way Cyc does, but have a very fast, efficient and powerful conceptual approach to the world with a massive amount of recursive conceptual inference.
Source?
Re:One Genius' Lonely Crusade to Teach a Computer Common Sense
by asynchronous on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @09:13AM
(#41787609)
This isn’t Reddit, evaluate the statement without needing to link to some mainstream media outlet.
Re:One Genius' Lonely Crusade to Teach a Computer Common Sense
by freilanzer on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @09:42AM
(#41787889)
The OP is making a statement about how humans think and why this is at odds with Cyc. I don't think it is wrong to ask about a source on this. Otherwise I can claim anything. This has nothing to do with Reddit.
> Humans do think with first order predicate calculus. We juggle a bunch of statements/rules the way Cyc does, and don't have a very fast, efficient and powerful conceptual approach to the world with a massive amount of recursive conceptual inference.
Great discussion, thanks.
Re:One Genius' Lonely Crusade to Teach a Computer Common Sense
by gibsonf1 on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @11:00AM
(#41788621)
I am the source (working on conceptual computing since the late 90s), and have built a conceptual computing platform based on it (In common lisp of course): https://graphmetrix.com/trinpod-server
Effectively, you need to understand (compute with) what concepts are before using them in statements. And the most common mistake is to confuse the definition of a concept with the concept itself, as happens typically with knowledge graphs.