News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:One Genius' Lonely Crusade to Teach a Computer Common Sense by gibsonf1 on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @08:33AM (#41787204)
The fundamental flaw with Lenat's approach is that humans do not think with first order predicate calculus. We do not juggle a bunch of statements/rules the way Cyc does, but have a very fast, efficient and powerful conceptual approach to the world with a massive amount of recursive conceptual inference.

Effectively, you need to understand (compute with) what concepts are before using them in statements. And the most common mistake is to confuse the definition of a concept with the concept itself, as happens typically with knowledge graphs.

Re:One Genius' Lonely Crusade to Teach a Computer Common Sense by arethuza on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @10:12AM (#41788194)
That argument sounds awfully like Drew McDermott's A Critique of Pure Reason from 1987 which was one of the things that made me get out of the "good old fashioned" AI world in the mid 1990s.
Re:One Genius' Lonely Crusade to Teach a Computer Common Sense by gbasin on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @08:39AM (#41787258)
this was my main takeaway from 20th century philosophy lol
Re:One Genius' Lonely Crusade to Teach a Computer Common Sense by freilanzer on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @09:00AM (#41787475)
> The fundamental flaw with Lenat's approach is that humans do not think with first order predicate calculus. We do not juggle a bunch of statements/rules the way Cyc does, but have a very fast, efficient and powerful conceptual approach to the world with a massive amount of recursive conceptual inference.

Source?

Re:One Genius' Lonely Crusade to Teach a Computer Common Sense by asynchronous on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @09:13AM (#41787609)
This isn’t Reddit, evaluate the statement without needing to link to some mainstream media outlet.
Re:One Genius' Lonely Crusade to Teach a Computer Common Sense by freilanzer on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @09:42AM (#41787889)
The OP is making a statement about how humans think and why this is at odds with Cyc. I don't think it is wrong to ask about a source on this. Otherwise I can claim anything. This has nothing to do with Reddit.

> Humans do think with first order predicate calculus. We juggle a bunch of statements/rules the way Cyc does, and don't have a very fast, efficient and powerful conceptual approach to the world with a massive amount of recursive conceptual inference.

Great discussion, thanks.

Re:One Genius' Lonely Crusade to Teach a Computer Common Sense by gibsonf1 on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @11:00AM (#41788621)
I am the source (working on conceptual computing since the late 90s), and have built a conceptual computing platform based on it (In common lisp of course): https://graphmetrix.com/trinpod-server