News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: What's the "best" book you've ever read? by wakawaka28 on Monday October 07, 2024 @07:54PM (#41772386)
Taxing land is definitely not a revolutionary concept. What made George famous is that he wrote a manifesto that blamed the "rich" land owners for all the ills of society, and proposed that solving the problem would be as simple as levying another tax. It sounds good but has little substance or relation to actual economics.
Re:Ask HN: What's the "best" book you've ever read? by slwvx on Monday October 07, 2024 @08:12PM (#41772512)
I'd prefer a more substantive critique than an ad-hominem statement
Re:Ask HN: What's the "best" book you've ever read? by wakawaka28 on Monday October 07, 2024 @08:25PM (#41772585)
That is not an ad hominem statement. It is an opinion about how overblown the idea is and why George is famous for it. Some property tax is probably a good idea. Does this dude deserve credit for the idea? No. Is he right in asserting that all poverty results from a lack of access to land? No. Will property tax make the economy go brrr? No. The idea of choosing the uses of land by taxing the hell out of random entities just because you think have the money to pay for it is tantamount to communism. I'm not about to read a whole book on the supposed revolutionary merits of property tax, thank you very much.
Re:Ask HN: What's the "best" book you've ever read? by llamaimperative on Monday October 07, 2024 @08:58PM (#41772775)
Oh yeah, now that I got to this comment of yours… it’s very evident you haven’t read it by your (honestly, I don’t say this just to be insulting) downright cartoonish misunderstanding of its contents.

Even more impressive, it’s obvious you haven’t even read a decent critique or summary of it.

You should consider it! There’s a reason for its stature :)

Re:Ask HN: What's the "best" book you've ever read? by wakawaka28 on Monday October 07, 2024 @09:15PM (#41772857)
I disagree. I listened to an hour long, glowing summary of it and read about it on Wikipedia. It is just not convincing to me. The only thing cartoonish is how hard people praise it, considering we already have property taxes much like George wanted, which are often quite high and don't add to the economy. Property taxes like that are very close to communism, especially if you take it to an extreme. The higher the taxes, the less you actually own anything.

I have also had the displeasure of arguing with someone who thinks Henry George had the right idea. The dude was literally defending the communist Chinese "property" model which is just a 70 year lease from the government.

Calling my view extreme is like saying that an atheist is religious. Just because I don't accept this idea and all the ensuing conclusions, does not make my views extreme or unreasonable, much less "cartoonish"...

Re:Ask HN: What's the "best" book you've ever read? by llamaimperative on Monday October 07, 2024 @09:24PM (#41772911)
Sorry, I didn’t mean cartoonish in the sense of extreme (quite the opposite), I meant it in the sense of not understanding what you’re talking about.

You’ve stuffed an impressive number of misunderstandings into these few comments, but I’m not sure I’ll be able to help you unwind them except to say you should read the book.

Re:Ask HN: What's the "best" book you've ever read? by wakawaka28 on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @12:49AM (#41773940)
Well, perhaps the people glorifying this book are the ones who have misunderstood it. They certainly did not convey anything about it to me besides what I have said and criticized here. I don't feel the need to read it one way or another. If the main idea is simply that property tax can be good, I already think that. If the main idea is that property tax is likely to fix poverty and inequality (as I have been led to believe), nothing in it can possibly convince me of that. On a similar note, I don't think that reading a Bible will make me doubt the theory of evolution, or the laws of physics. And you can't convince me that the Bible is not contrary to those principles, because I know better than that.
Re:Ask HN: What's the "best" book you've ever read? by llamaimperative on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @06:43AM (#41775853)
That’s not the main idea. In fact it’s the opposite of the main idea. You do not understand what you’re arguing against, and it’s not a subtle misunderstanding either. You are wrong on the very core of the idea.
Re:Ask HN: What's the "best" book you've ever read? by wakawaka28 on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:55AM (#41776844)
So, again, if I misunderstand the ideas and nature of the book, it is because fans of the book do not understand it either. I think we are disagreeing about definitions. I looked at a wiki page about Georgism and I am even more convinced that this is the case and it is being co-opted by communist/socialist influencers. Anyway, it does not matter. This whole thread is going nowhere.
Re:Ask HN: What's the "best" book you've ever read? by llamaimperative on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @09:11AM (#41776983)
No, it's because you misunderstand what you've heard and you are demonstrably impervious to doubting and therefore improving your own understanding.

The "disagreement about definitions" is the substance of the disagreement. You do not understand the terms that are being used, therefore you do not understand the argument being made.

You say up above that all taxes are just taxes, so a conversation with you about tax policy is bound to roughly a first grade level because you've chosen not to learn what words mean.

Re:Ask HN: What's the "best" book you've ever read? by RockyRoads on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @02:15PM (#41780176)
As a bystander, I am baffled. You are clearly misunderstanding the core ideas of the book, yet adamant that you wouldn’t learn anything from reading it. Your reduction of the ideas to communism is juvenile. In fact, the alternative tax system proposed would keep value produced from labor in the private hands of the laborer — in essence the exact opposite of communism. Taxation can take many forms, and the details matter quite a lot. Until you open your mind to realize this, even if you still disagreed with the proposals, I think you’ll continue failing to understand why Progress and Poverty is globally one of the most widely distributed political economy books in history.
Re:Ask HN: What's the "best" book you've ever read? by llamaimperative on Monday October 07, 2024 @08:57PM (#41772772)
I suspect you don’t know what you’re talking about based on your subsequent conflation of property tax with a land value tax.

That’s a good shibboleth for “never have actually engaged this idea.”

Re:Ask HN: What's the "best" book you've ever read? by wakawaka28 on Monday October 07, 2024 @09:17PM (#41772870)
Property tax is a land value tax. You literally pay a percentage of some notional value of your property every year, largely based on how you use it. The fact you don't recognize that is a good shibboleth for "never have engaged with the real world."
Re:Ask HN: What's the "best" book you've ever read? by llamaimperative on Monday October 07, 2024 @09:29PM (#41772932)
A portion of a property tax is a land value tax, but 1) it’s only one portion of it and 2) it’s the opposite of the portion that you just described.

It’s very specifically not based on how you use the land. And that’s literally the core fact of the system. The two calculations yield entirely different incentives. It’s clear you misunderstood it. I recommend reading the book itself as it will be clearer than you’ve apparently had it explained.

Re:Ask HN: What's the "best" book you've ever read? by wakawaka28 on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @12:42AM (#41773901)
>It’s very specifically not based on how you use the land.

Sorry but you are wrong. Farmers and homeowners pay less than investors. If you build expensive stuff on the property (put another way, if you USE it to do something expensive) you generally pay more.

Again, I don't need to read a whole book, much less one based on pure idealism and with no thought given to real economic data and real human nature, to know that it is generally wrong. I don't need to read the whole book here any more than I need to read the whole bible to doubt it. You need to learn about the real world and stop assuming you know better than everyone just because you read an old book. Sometimes a book review is actually enough to get the gist. I even got reviews from people who thought highly of the book, and I was unconvinced.

Re:Ask HN: What's the "best" book you've ever read? by danielhep on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @01:25AM (#41774083)
> If you build expensive stuff on the property you generally pay more.

This is not Land Value Tax. Georgism is an argument against this concept of taxing based on what you do with the land.

Re:Ask HN: What's the "best" book you've ever read? by wakawaka28 on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @01:42AM (#41774147)
So, am I to understand that prime beach real estate is to be taxed the same as a plot in a desert or swamp? There is clearly a lot of trouble with taxing land, because an inherent part of its value is what you can do with it. People pay premium for land that is useful and desireable. The structures placed on land and the values thereof are proportional to this desirability and economic utility.

Furthermore, it might be necessary to use land for farming or warehouses when it is more profitably used for residential structures. A free market might eventually sort out higher food prices that can cover the taxes, but I think we can all agree that it's better to not arbitrarily increase taxes on a necessity like food.

Re:Ask HN: What's the "best" book you've ever read? by reshlo on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @06:10AM (#41775584)
> So, am I to understand that prime beach real estate is to be taxed the same as a plot in a desert or swamp?

Why would that be the case? A beachfront plot would likely have a higher value than a plot in a desert or swamp, so the tax levied on the beachfront plot’s value would, of course, be higher. It’s a tax on the land’s value, not a tax on the size of the plot.

Re:Ask HN: What's the "best" book you've ever read? by wakawaka28 on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:38AM (#41776684)
The value of land is largely subjective. It is based on demand, among other things. If the government assigns arbitrarily high or low value to land based on hypothetical worlds where the land could be used for high rises, factories, or whatever as opposed to what economics has proven is the best actual use of the land and its best estimated price, that is just a terrible version of the same thing we have now.
Re:Ask HN: What's the "best" book you've ever read? by pyrados on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @12:32PM (#41789791)
Assessors observe market activity. The 'purchase price' when you buy land is based on the highest and best potential use of land. The "Land Value Tax" merely appropriates this observed value for public expense (and potential dividend distribution).

The fact that you compared 'prime real estate' to swampland or desert demonstrates a fundamental misunderstanding of ad valorem taxation and land rent generally. While the rate should be the same (ideally as close to 100% as we can get without causing issues) the actual -value- would be dramatically different.

Under your hypothetical question, the desert and/or swampland could very well have 0 rental value, which means the tax would collect 0 from these locations. 100% of $0 = 0.

Re:Ask HN: What's the "best" book you've ever read? by llamaimperative on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @06:52AM (#41775911)
Correct. In fact it’s the entire premise. If one doesn’t understand this fact then they do not understand literally anything about Georgism.

GP is woefully confused and so darn sure of it!

Re:Ask HN: What's the "best" book you've ever read? by llamaimperative on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @06:41AM (#41775845)
lol, you are unambiguously, 100% wrong.

By analogy: “I don’t need to read On The Origin of Species because I’m already familiar with the idea that a singular designer made all of life on earth and I don’t believe it! I already know that actually three intelligent designers made everything on earth. No sense in reading Darwin, who is an idiot for believing there’s only one intelligent designer!”

Like it is a satirical level of misunderstanding. To clarify, in case you’ve also listened to a podcast or whatever: Darwin doesn’t argue there’s one designer. George doesn’t argue for property tax.

There’s nowhere for the conversation to go if you think otherwise and are digging in your heels on it, so I’ll just reassure you that you’re exhibiting satirical levels of misunderstanding and frankly shocking foolishness to not be reacting to point blank demonstrations of your wrongness.

Re:Ask HN: What's the "best" book you've ever read? by wakawaka28 on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:48AM (#41776784)
No, this is like saying I'm not going to read "Origin of Species" because it is dated and redundant. You don't have to disagree with something to know it's not worth your time.

>George doesn’t argue for property tax.

I don't think this is correct. But hey, you can redefine words all you want. A tax on land versus a tax on property, it's all just another tax.

>Like it is a satirical level of misunderstanding.

It's not satirical or a misunderstanding on my end as far as I'm concerned. I don't care to continue this discussion either. No matter what I'll say you'll demand I read the book, which I'm not going to do. When I compare it to anything you'll accuse me of misunderstanding something so basic as a tax. No thanks, take it up with someone who cares.

Re:Ask HN: What's the "best" book you've ever read? by llamaimperative on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @09:10AM (#41776977)
> I don't think this is correct.

Well, I know you don't think that's correct, but that's because you're wrong. You haven't read George's argument and I have, so we're just not on equal footing here.

> A tax on land versus a tax on property, it's all just another tax.

An income tax is also a property tax is also a land tax is also a capital gains tax, yes? This is one way in which you're wrong.

And no, if you didn't exhibit both a ridiculous misunderstanding and an astounding level of confidence in your ignorance, I wouldn't implore you to read the book. You're obviously welcome to carry your ignorance with pride though, so have a good week!