News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by Teever on Monday October 07, 2024 @06:31PM (#41771806)
When we'll reach this inflection point with jet fighters?

I remain skeptical that the F-35 will prove to be a prudent expenditure of resources both financial and in terms of R&D.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by jacoblambda on Monday October 07, 2024 @07:34PM (#41772263)
Idk how they wouldn't compete in terms of financials.

They are in effect the specced-down mass production version of the F-22 and are comparable in terms of cost relative to similar fifth generation fighters (and even comparable to many fourth generation fights) but go toe to toe with or outperform the competition.

This stacks the deck such that the F-35 will be a peer to or superior to any "opposition" aircraft or anti-air weapon system while the US keeps the F-22 around to serve as a dogfighter that is reserved for fighting the rare circumstance of something that's legitimately a threat to an F-35.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by epolanski on Monday October 07, 2024 @08:34PM (#41772644)
This is all theoretical until properly tested.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by Teever on Monday October 07, 2024 @09:28PM (#41772928)
Why can't small, cheap drones do to the modern fighters what they're doing to modern tanks?
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by rgmerk on Monday October 07, 2024 @10:04PM (#41773144)
Because small, cheap drones can’t fly at supersonic speeds at long enough range to matter.

Drones that can do that are called “anti-aircraft missiles”.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by Teever on Monday October 07, 2024 @11:07PM (#41773476)
What are the speeds and the distances required to take down a jet like an F-35?

Are you absolutely certain that there's no other way to take down modern fighter aircraft?

Like isn't that the lesson from the Ukraine war w.r.t. tanks? That there are cheaper, more effective tools out there to take out state of the art equipment.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by MindSpunk on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @02:44AM (#41774409)
Well your drone would need to fly faster than an f35 to catch up, maneuver more effectively than an f35 to hit a defending f35 and have a sufficiently complex sensor array to track and defeat the f35 autonomously.

We have many drones much cheaper than an f35 that can do this already. They're called AIM-9, AIM-120, Meteor. Or if you're Russian they're called R77, or R73.

These are, of course, anti-aircraft missiles.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by Teever on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @05:28AM (#41775334)
Do you think it is plausible that we will see an incredibly cheap anti-aircraft missile that can destroy the latest fighter aircraft just like we've seen incredibly cheap drones that can destroy the latest tanks?

Why or why not?

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by simiones on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @06:36AM (#41775805)
For one, because of physics: it's easy to hit a slow moving tank from a flying vehicle. It's impossible to hit a fast-moving flying vehicle from a slower moving one. And you can't make a cheap light rotor-based drone move as fast a jet-engine-powered plane no matter how hart you try.

For another, R&D: we've been working on fast autonomous flying vehicles to take down aircraft for decades: as the poster above keeps explaining, they're called AA missiles, and are extremely expensive, and even still have a hard time actually hitting a plain. Drones are an innovation in fighting tanks because they are much more maneuverable than traditional AT weapons and thus can more easily find chinks in the tank's armor. You could have always used the extreme maneuverability of AA rockets to hit those same chinks in the armor, but the cost was too high; drones were cheaper. AA rockets are extremely cost effective against plains though, as those jets are monumentally more expensive than a tank.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by Teever on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @09:45PM (#41783660)
> Do you think it is plausible that we will see an incredibly cheap anti-aircraft missile ...
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by simiones on Thursday October 10, 2024 @05:07AM (#41797017)
I misread the question a bit, sorry. Still, I believe the arguments hold - while I'm sure that it's possible to make cheaper missiles, especially if we take into account the markup typically associated with military contracts, I don't think there is any room to go anywhere near the cost savings that cheap drones brought against tanks.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by jacoblambda on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @06:40PM (#41782517)
The issue is that the F-35 when it's actually being competitive is practically invisible. The US actually has generally had to operate it without stealth coatings or while broadcasting a radio beacon while doing comparisons or competitions against other crafts and weapon systems because in an actual combat environment, an F-35 fit for stealth is completely invisible to electronics (and to a measurable degree eyesight) well within F-35 weapon systems' effective ranges.

So essentially you can't see an F-35 until it is already lined up to kill you. That tends to make it pretty difficult to hit it.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by JohnBooty on Monday October 07, 2024 @10:26PM (#41773263)
Are you talking about cheap drones replacing modern fighters, or cheap drones shooting down modern fighters?

They will absolutely replace modern fighters to a degree and already have to an extent, like we've seen in Ukraine with drones serving as close infantry support etc. instead of manned aircraft.

There are still some things "cheap" drones won't be able to do.

Specifically, if you want to carry big bombs and missiles, you need a large aircraft even if it's unmanned. The drone is also presumably going to need to be able to survive enemy air defenses to some extent. So you wind up with a big expensive drone like the MQ-9 Reaper ($30mil plus, lol) that is approaching the size and complexity of a manned fighter.

Also, and I'm not sure if this is what you meant, but "small, cheap drones" are not likely to be shooting down modern fighters in the way that small cheap drones are currently killing tanks directly.

If you want an aircraft that can fly at mach 1.6+ and shoot missiles at other things (some of them stealthy) traveling at mach 1.6+, you are going to wind up with something fairly close to the size/cost/complexity of an F-35 even if you don't have a human being sitting inside.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by bigfatkitten on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @12:06AM (#41773728)
And without the ability to operate in EMCON like an F-35 or F-22, unless it's fully autonomous.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by jacoblambda on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @07:33PM (#41782919)
Alternatively if/when starship is up and running it should be pretty trivial to ferry a lot of JDAM-esque weapons up to an orbital launch platform. From there you could practically throw bombs down in a suborbital path to a target and let the JDAM fins guide it in through the atmosphere.

A starship already costs around 90 million USD at cost (estimated based on parts cost currently) and is intended to cost around 10 million USD per launch commercially if it's able to be reused regularly.

And a single launch could carry a lot of bombs (like 50-400 based on the size). So on the high end after factoring in the cost of the bombs, amortising the cost of the initial orbital platform, and assuming a higher cost of like 120 million USD for a single launch, that would still almost certainly come out cheaper than sacrificing an MQ-9 or a much more expensive missile. And of course if you can get that cost down to 10 million USD per launch then other than artillery, that's going to be the cheapest way to deliver ordinance to any location in the world by far (after factoring in the cost of flight time for jets, etc).

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by jandrewrogers on Monday October 07, 2024 @10:25PM (#41773258)
Truly modern fighters have advanced defenses across the EM spectrum. Hardening a drone against those defenses makes them no longer “small” and “cheap”. Also, drones typically have much lower speed than a modern fighter. An air-to-air missile is essentially a single-use drone where a key property is that it is much faster than the fighter, but this makes it expensive.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by JohnBooty on Monday October 07, 2024 @10:36PM (#41773324)

    An air-to-air missile is essentially a single-use drone
Yeah.

And barring some big advance, an air-to-air missile can't be any smaller than it is currently. It needs to carry enough explosive to damage the target aircraft, and it needs enough fuel to travel at supersonic speeds for a long enough distance to actually intercept the target.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by Teever on Monday October 07, 2024 @11:04PM (#41773460)
But can it be cheaper?

That's the lesson from drones vs tanks.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by dalai on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @03:53AM (#41774755)
I think it would already be a big advantage not needing a very expensive launch platform like a fighter jet, even if the unit price of the drone was a bit higher than that of the missile.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by simiones on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @06:40AM (#41775833)
No, because all the things you got rid of to make drones cheap when fighting tanks are required when fighting fighters. You only need to be slightly faster and slightly more maneuverable than your target to take it down, while older AT weapons were much faster: so slower drones could still be just as effective. This is not true for fighter jets.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by Teever on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @05:49PM (#41782129)
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by simiones on Thursday October 10, 2024 @05:04AM (#41796996)
> Ares is building a new class of anti-ship cruise missiles.

Not sure what this has to do with my claims about not being able to use cheap drones for taking down fighter jets. Military ships, like tanks, are also somewhat slower and somewhat less maneuverable than fighter jets, I believe.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by Atotalnoob on Monday October 07, 2024 @10:04PM (#41773142)
F35 platform is built to allow the pilot to control “fleets” of drones.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by spacebanana7 on Monday October 07, 2024 @07:14PM (#41772124)
Without a capable stealth fighter the US & allies could lose air superiority to China very quickly in the Indo Pacific. And operations in the Middle East could become much more high risk from SAMs.

However it’s interesting to compare the F35 program to the alternative of producing several hundred F22s, or some other stealth solution.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by jacoblambda on Monday October 07, 2024 @07:38PM (#41772286)
The F-22 is still a better dogfighting craft than the F-35. In many many ways the F-35 is effectively a commoditised, specced down version of the F-22 geared towards general multi-role operation while the F-22 is hyper-specialised towards killing any other aircraft.

And importantly, the US wants to export the F-35 but keep the F-22 close to chest so that should push come to shove, the US can always maintain air superiority.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by throwaway2037 on Thursday October 10, 2024 @08:15AM (#41798071)
Why don't you think aircraft carrier deployed F/A-18 Super Hornet would be effective against China to protect Taiwan?
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by spacebanana7 on Thursday October 10, 2024 @09:29AM (#41798589)
As a measure of deterrence, carries with Hornets can be useful. They do make it more difficult and expensive for the Chinese to take Taiwan.

However, it's unrealistic for them to establish anything like air superiority over the Taiwan Straits. Each carrier has fewer than 100 aircraft, and only a couple can be deployed to the region at a time. The opposing PLAAF has over 2000 combat aircraft including hundreds of stealth planes.

For the US to be competitive such a contest they need planes that are qualitatively better than the Chinese ones by a huge margin. American advantages in stealth, missile range and avionics are essential just to stay in the game.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by CrimsonCape on Monday October 07, 2024 @07:07PM (#41772075)
In retrospect the money would have been better spent on building a Berry-compliant drone making company that can build consumer and attack drones.

Instead, the retrospective will likely be: "I guess we should now build drones in addition to our jet fighter." Double the effort, half the efficiency, half the result.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by Teever on Monday October 07, 2024 @07:21PM (#41772170)
Yeah that's where I'm at with this topic too.

If we use the Ukraine war as a template for the next major war that the US faces (possibly against China) -- does the United States have the industrial capability to produce the tens to hundreds of millions of drones necessary to win?

Like can it produce the propellers, the frames, the motors, the batteries, the ICs to make a FPV drone that blows up in an enemy soldiers face?

Can that supply chain be made in the US and how long can will it take to make?

Is this a priority for the United States? Why or why not?

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by jacoblambda on Monday October 07, 2024 @07:39PM (#41772292)
> Like can it produce the propellers, the frames, the motors, the batteries, the ICs to make a FPV drone that blows up in an enemy soldiers face?

Yes

> Can that supply chain be made in the US and how long can will it take to make?

In a limited capacity yes but also in like 5 or so years the answer will be an unequivocal yes.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by Teever on Monday October 07, 2024 @09:27PM (#41772923)
I'm interested to know more about this. Can you provide more details?
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by HeWhoLurksLate on Monday October 07, 2024 @09:57PM (#41773106)
TSMC is building significant, cutting-edge fab capacity in the US at present
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by JohnBooty on Monday October 07, 2024 @10:41PM (#41773349)
It's very, very unclear to me what would happen to TSMC's American operations if China invades/seizes/blockades Taiwan.

How independent would TSMC's American foundries be if cut off and forced to operate autonomously if US/China war breaks out?

I am sure that the goal is full independence but I have no idea what the current state of that is, what the state of it will be in 5-10 years etc.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by Teever on Monday October 07, 2024 @11:04PM (#41773468)
Is it cost effective or logistically scalable to have the kinds of ICs that are used in current cheap FPV drones to be made on the latest fabs?
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by jacoblambda on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @06:35PM (#41782478)
Well the US has a ton of larger process size fabs. There's at least 100 fabs of varying sizes and processes in the US as well as internal supply chain for materials, testing, and assembly. (Where do you think most of the semiconductors containing classified designs are manufactured)

Most are much smaller and more specialised/less automated so they don't have the same kind of production but there are a lot of fabs in the US and a lot of fab knowledge. Of all the countries, the US is one of the few that could probably survive a semiconductor industry collapse outside.

And many of those semiconductors in cheap FPV drones likely are actually fabbed in the US or could easily be fabbed in the US by Intel, Infineon, Texas Instruments, pSemi, NXP, Bosch, Renesas, Micron, onsemi, Analog Devices, Honeywell, Polar, GlobalFoundaries, Microchip, or Samsung, just to name a few non-military facing companies with significant fab operations in the US.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by zmgsabst on Monday October 07, 2024 @11:30PM (#41773588)
The US is already investigating that, eg, with targeting drones backed by larger craft carrying large numbers of missiles.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by rjurney on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @12:03AM (#41773720)
Oh they will. They are the sensor-fused quarterbacks of drone warfare.