This tripped me up too until point 3 in the piece:
> If you are wondering whether or not something counts as weird nonfiction, consider its weirdness. Modern mockumentaries do not work because there is no uncertainty; the documentary element is used to advance the plot, mug at the camera, key the viewer in.
I read this as: non-fiction elements in service of advancing the plot is a strike against.
Really, "weird nonfiction" is whatever the author wants it to be. The examples are a total grab bag IMHO.
By this definition, Blair Witch Project seems to fit. Is that right? The examples given in the article seem to indicate a different intention or tone.