News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Insider Trader Had All the Answers by twoodfin on Saturday October 05, 2024 @07:40AM (#41749202)
Another way to see that would be the Supreme Court affirming that if the SEC accuses you of what is clearly common law fraud, and wants to penalize you millions of dollars, they are required by the Constitution to bring those charges to Article III courts where you can exercise all the rights of the accused recognized by the Constitution (most specifically in this case, trial by jury).
Re:Insider Trader Had All the Answers by walrushunter on Saturday October 05, 2024 @08:01AM (#41749303)
There's no other way to see it.

I'm not sure why the parent comment decided to bring politics into it. You'd think the idea that the government shouldn't be able to accuse you of a crime and take your money without a trial would be bipartisan.

Re:Insider Trader Had All the Answers by cheschire on Saturday October 05, 2024 @08:16AM (#41749362)
There was a recent video by John Oliver going deep into the politics of the supreme court, so it's in the public discourse enough recently that the two concepts of justice and politics are probably linked for some folks.

It's one of those annoying things that tends to happen a month out from presidential elections I guess.

Re:Insider Trader Had All the Answers by ThunderSizzle on Sunday October 06, 2024 @07:42AM (#41756433)
John Oliver has enough bad takes and lies that I'm at the point that if he says something, I assume it's a lie at this point. Or at least his conclusions are lies
Re:Insider Trader Had All the Answers by cheschire on Sunday October 06, 2024 @01:37PM (#41758664)
Yeah I tend to take it more as satire or wild exaggeration than real investigative reporting.

When his buddy Joel McHale, who also acted on the fictional TV show "Community" along with John Oliver, tried making his own hot take comedy news show, it really put things in perspective for me.

Now I watch it for the comedy aspect as much as anything I see on other news media these days. Take what I see with John Oliver amped up to a solid 9 or 10, divide it by 10, and that's probably how serious or impactful the thing actually is that he is reporting on.

Re:Insider Trader Had All the Answers by wpietri on Saturday October 05, 2024 @09:41AM (#41749762)
> I'm not sure why the parent comment decided to bring politics into it.

The Federalist Society and their fellow travelers have been politicizing the Supreme Court for literal decades. To talk about the Supreme Court while avoiding any mention of politics is a itself a stridently political act.

Re:Insider Trader Had All the Answers by skybrian on Saturday October 05, 2024 @02:08PM (#41751729)
Further back then that. Supreme Court has been a political institution all along. (The Marbury vs. Madison decision was an interesting political maneuver.)
Re:Insider Trader Had All the Answers by tbrownaw on Saturday October 05, 2024 @09:56AM (#41749874)
> I'm not sure why the parent comment decided to bring politics into it.

It's the standard way to denounce decisions you don't like.

Re:Insider Trader Had All the Answers by adrr on Saturday October 05, 2024 @08:03AM (#41749310)
So you request a jury trial. I don’t get what your point is. Its a civil penality because the SEC isn’t a law enforcement agency and it enforces regulations. Regulations have been around since George Washington was president when the Whiskey Act was passed allowing the government to form regulations on taxing whiskey including levying fines on people.
Re:Insider Trader Had All the Answers by twoodfin on Saturday October 05, 2024 @08:57AM (#41749541)
You couldn’t “request a jury trial”. That was the point of the suit.

Yes, civil penalties are a thing. But the argument that prevailed was that this was not a penalty for speeding or not paying enough tax, this was a penalty for alleged actions that amounted to common law fraud & Congress can’t delegate the adjudication of common law—civil or criminal—to an administrative agency.

Re:Insider Trader Had All the Answers by WrongAssumption on Saturday October 05, 2024 @10:06AM (#41749962)
And regulations are still enforceable. What is not enforceable is to make a regulation that parallels an existing law, and deny a federal trial because it’s now a “regulation”.