Re:Why Is the Speed of Light So Fast? (Part 1)
by fanf2 on Friday October 04, 2024 @11:30AM
(#41742450)
I thought laser fusion only exists for nuclear weapons research, and there isn’t any path from the current experiments to a power plant.
Re:Why Is the Speed of Light So Fast? (Part 1)
by PaulHoule on Friday October 04, 2024 @02:01PM
(#41743929)
That’s what I think. The efficiency of lasers is awful and they take hours to cool off after a shot whereas a commercial fusion power plant needs a shot rate between one every few seconds to several per second.
A heavy ion power plant is possible in terms of the physics but needs to be the scale of a fission power plant to work at all and is projected to cost maybe 2x what an AP1000 costs assuming everything goes well and we know things usually work worse than you expect. So nobody is interested in funding a full-scale prototype, a reasonable development plan is you build several linac barrels and a test fusion facility and expect to rebuild that and add more barrels. It probably costs about what Musk spent on Twitter in the end.
Re:Why Is the Speed of Light So Fast? (Part 1)
by api on Friday October 04, 2024 @07:14PM
(#41746383)
That’s the funding pitch but I’ve heard the scientists claim they want to study it for possible power use.
Re:Why Is the Speed of Light So Fast? (Part 1)
by api on Friday October 04, 2024 @11:27AM
(#41742420)
I'd never even heard of HIF. I wonder how it could scale with today's superconductors, which are far better than what we had in the 70s.
Re:Why Is the Speed of Light So Fast? (Part 1)
by PaulHoule on Friday October 04, 2024 @11:38AM
(#41742535)
See https://cds.cern.ch/record/2743157/files/Seeman2020_Chapter_... you can get better Q for superconducting linacs and also operate them in CW mode without fear of burning them up. Off the cuff I'd speculate that superconducting magnets that can support 2x the magnetic field might support 2x the accelerating gradient but we are talking AC operation here, not DC.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heavy_ion_fusion
the argument is that "highly efficient laser" might be an oxymoron and if you were serious about commercial fusion you might trade lasers for much more efficient particle accelerators that run at a viable shot rate. Trouble is that you need heavy ions (lead) at 8GeV and it takes multiple barrels that are a km long or so... A huge machine that might be competitive with lasers for a commercial power plant but that can't be built in a subscale prototype. It might not be compatible with the magnetic nozzle though as 8GeV is not relativistic for lead ions.