C++ fully monomorphizes class/function templates, and therefore incurs 0 overhead while unlocking a ton of inlining, unlike Go.
For example Rust's name.contains(|c| c == 'x' || (c >= '0' && c <= '9')) gets you code which just checks whether there are any ASCII digits or a lowercase latin x in name. If you don't have monomorphisation this ends up with a function call overhead for every single character in name because the "shape" of this callable is the same as that of every callable and a single implementation has to call here.
Is Go's choice a valid one? Yes. Is it somehow the "best of all worlds"? Not even close.
Edit: I think the Go compiler might actually be smart enough to inline in this kind of case. See line 113 of the assembly listing here: https://godbolt.org/z/8qGdzeKcG
Do you have an example of a "good modern C compiler" which inlines the function? Presumably this is a magic special case for say, qsort ?
The broader point is that compilers (including the Go compiler, it seems) can and do make this kind of optimization via inlining, and that this doesn't have much to do with any particular approach to generics.
We got into this with the claim (never substantiated) that this works for the C library function qsort, which is notable because it does indeed work for the C++ and Rust standard library sorts which are done the way I described.
It does not surprise me that Rust inlines more aggressively than Go, but that doesn't have anything much to do with differences between Rust and Go generics or type systems.
Adopting the type-level fiction that every lambda has a unique type does not fundamentally make inlining any easier for the compiler. It may well be that in Rust the monomorphization triggered by this feature of the type system leads to more inlining than would otherwise happen. But that is just an idiosyncrasy of Rust. Compilers can do whatever kind of inlining they like regardless of whether or not they think that every anonymous function has its own unique type.
Edit: One further thing that's worth noting here is that the Go compiler does do cross-module inlining. So (unlike in the case of a typical C compiler) it is not the case that the kind of inlining we've been talking about here can only occur if the function and the lambda exist in the same module or source file. https://utcc.utoronto.ca/~cks/space/blog/programming/GoInlin...
What Go developers wanted was a solution to the problem of having to repeat things like simple algorithms (see e.g. slice tricks) once for each type they would ever need to operate on, and also a solution to the problem of confusing interfaces dancing around the lack of generics (see e.g. the standard sort package.) Go generics solve that and only that.
Every programming language has to choose how to balance and prioritize values when making design decisions. Go favors simplicity over expressiveness and also seems to prioritize keeping compile-time speeds fast over maximizing runtime performance, and their generics design is pretty consistent with that.
The Go generics design did not win over anyone who was already a Go hater because if you already didn't like Go it's probably safe to say that the things Go values most are not the things that you value most. Yes, everyone likes faster compile times, but many people would prefer faster runtime performance. Personally I think that it's worth balancing runtime performance with fast compile times, as I prefer to keep the edit-compile-test latency very low; that Go can compile and run thousands of practical tests in a couple seconds is pretty useful for me as a developer. But on the other hand, you may feel that it's silly to optimize for fast compile times as software will be ran many more times than it will be compiled, so it makes sense to pay more up front. I know some people will treat this like there's an objectively correct answer, even though it's pretty clear there is not. (Even calculating whether it makes sense to pay more up front is really, really hard. It is not guaranteed.)
So actually, I would like type erasure generics in C. I still write some C code here and there and I hate reaching into C++ just for templates. C is so nice for implementing basic data structures and yet so terrible for actually using them and just this tiny little improvement would make a massive, massive difference. Does it give you the sheer power that C++ templates give you? Well, no, but it's a huge quality of life improvement that meshes very well with the values that C already has, so while it won't win over people who don't like C, it will improve the life of people who already do, and I think that's a better way to evolve a language.
That's not true. Go's generics are monomorphized, when it makes sense (different shapes) and not monomorphized when it doesn't (same shapes). It's a hybrid approach to combine the best of both worlds: https://go.googlesource.com/proposal/+/refs/heads/master/des...