Re:Nvidia Loses Huge GPU Order Due To Linux Blob
by Silhouette on Thursday June 28, 2012 @09:21AM
(#4171556)
Openness is great, other things being equal, but in the graphics card market other things certainly aren't equal. A huge amount of R&D goes into the drivers rather than the cards themselves, because better drivers offer a substantial commercial advantage over the competition.
If that advantage is reduced -- or even becomes a liability -- because you gave away the secrets that you spent a lot of time and money learning, then there is no longer any reason to spend that time and money in the first place, and not even your own drivers will benefit.
This is the problem with almost any Internet debate about intellectual property or open development processes. It's easy to see the benefit tomorrow if you just force everything open today, but you have to consider the implications for next week as well.
In this particular case, a lot of people are calling NVIDIA names and assuming they're being stupid. It's entirely possible that they have competent management who have looked at the loss for this one deal, balanced it against the ongoing loss of disclosing their proprietary driver techniques without an adequate level of control, and simply decided that it wasn't a good deal. Sure, it's 10,000,000 "lost" sales, but the global PC market alone ships upwards of 300,000,000 units every year, so this deal isn't even close to big enough to reshape the industry.
If that advantage is reduced -- or even becomes a liability -- because you gave away the secrets that you spent a lot of time and money learning, then there is no longer any reason to spend that time and money in the first place, and not even your own drivers will benefit.
This is the problem with almost any Internet debate about intellectual property or open development processes. It's easy to see the benefit tomorrow if you just force everything open today, but you have to consider the implications for next week as well.
In this particular case, a lot of people are calling NVIDIA names and assuming they're being stupid. It's entirely possible that they have competent management who have looked at the loss for this one deal, balanced it against the ongoing loss of disclosing their proprietary driver techniques without an adequate level of control, and simply decided that it wasn't a good deal. Sure, it's 10,000,000 "lost" sales, but the global PC market alone ships upwards of 300,000,000 units every year, so this deal isn't even close to big enough to reshape the industry.