Re:Show HN: 73,530 free book summaries in 40 languages (with...
by jazz3020 on Tuesday October 01, 2024 @04:10PM
(#41713549)
Okay, I really appreciate the feedback! Agree on the "meat in the bone," quotes, and LLM-like writing style (which is somewhat intended).
On-the-fly/cache: Yeah, I agree. We're only four months old—the number of on-the-fly summaries will go down significantly over time.
85%: What could make it 100%?
Pricing: I think that's fair. But considering Blinkist charges for $100+ for yearly, the $80 lifetime deal isn't that bad.
Legal: We actually drive a decent amount of traffic to Amazon, Audible, and Kindle. We're hoping to partner with the publishers and authors in the future whether in the form of revenue sharing or licsening.
From what I found based in some titles that I have read in the past and in comparison with Blinkist:
- The summaries here feels that has more "meat in the bone" in terms of bring complex ideas and have more bullet points
- Maybe it's about the prompting, but the language used you can definitely know that is generated by an LLM
- Having the direct quotes from the book after an initial definition of the theme of a chapter it's good
- The whole experience with the LLM kicking in on the fly, makes the whole experience quite bad; maybe you should consider have that pre-stored in some place
Honestly, I think your product it's 85% of theirs (and this is not something bad).
The pricing USD 79 for a lifetime it's OK, but without giving some kind of access or even make some library available it's quite hard to see someone paying for a library that you do not know the books that is in there.
From the legal perspective, I think you might be in some hot water since some publishers can dispute the fair use due to the fact that you're monetizing part of their content.