Re:Hasbro's Trademark for the Smell of Play-Doh
by iankp on Tuesday October 01, 2024 @01:09PM
(#41711208)
Are you talking about the Replica line by Maison Margiela, because those are obviously not trying to be bootlegs, they replicate smells from nature. However you're right, that fragrances are one of the most ripped off original works in existence, with machines to even analyze the composition in creating duplicates. Those master perfumers that make unique works of art through their studies and talents have it worse than Nike shoes.
Re:Hasbro's Trademark for the Smell of Play-Doh
by vorticalbox on Tuesday October 01, 2024 @12:54PM
(#41711001)
I was under the impression that trademarks were just granted and they are verified once they are challenged.
Re:Hasbro's Trademark for the Smell of Play-Doh
by RIMR on Tuesday October 01, 2024 @12:57PM
(#41711046)
That might be the case. I'm not a lawyer, but I do try to know as much as I can about IP law. Regardless, I would expect that Hasbro doesn't actually have the ability to protect this fragrance short of a SLAPP suite.
If someone duplicates your fragrance without duplicating your formula, they are free to do so, even for profit (See: The "Replica" brand of fragrances).
If they want to protect this smell as a form of IP, they need to patent their formula, not trademark a description of the scent. Even then, so long as competitors don't copy the formula, they are free to copy the smell.