Re:How a California county got PFAS out of its drinking water
by electricdreams on Monday September 30, 2024 @06:48PM
(#41702941)
What about fluoridation? They still putting rat poison in the water?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:How a California county got PFAS out of its drinking water
by JumpCrisscross on Monday September 30, 2024 @08:05PM
(#41703373)
> What about fluoridation? They still putting rat poison in the water?
Fluoride naturally occurs in groundwater at levels in excess of not only what we add to water on every continent, including to levels we consider unsafe (i.e. well in excess of fluoride-treated water) [1]. Humans have been consuming water with some level of fluoride in it for thousands of years. PFAS, meanwhile, are entirely anthropogenic.
Re:How a California county got PFAS out of its drinking water
by tmn on Monday September 30, 2024 @09:58PM
(#41703996)
This type of moving goal post rationalization always occurs on this topic. I can agree with you. And I don’t think added fluoride in my water is going to have any obvious health effect on me. But your points don’t justify why it’s still being added. What they do is rationalize why it’s not going to have any obvious health effects
Re:How a California county got PFAS out of its drinking water
by JumpCrisscross on Monday September 30, 2024 @10:49PM
(#41704218)
I’m arguing less for or against fluoride in drinking water than pointing out it’s irrelevant whataboutism (literally) in a discussion about PFAS.
Re:How a California county got PFAS out of its drinking water
by TheAceOfHearts on Monday September 30, 2024 @10:25PM
(#41704115)
The key issue with water fluoridation is that you can't control the dose. There's not really a strong consensus among countries whether it's optimal to add fluoride to drinking water, otherwise it would probably be the default choice everywhere. But we have better modern interventions that are just as effective: school-based dental care!
Re:How a California county got PFAS out of its drinking water
by Ferret7446 on Tuesday October 01, 2024 @03:50PM
(#41713345)
That's a poor argument. There are many things that can occur naturally in groundwater that you don't want to be drinking.
Re:How a California county got PFAS out of its drinking water
by llamaimperative on Monday September 30, 2024 @08:24PM
(#41703493)
Yes because, like the available science says that PFAS are dangerous, the available science says that fluoride is not (at the levels its used).
Hope that helps!
Re:How a California county got PFAS out of its drinking water
by o11c on Monday September 30, 2024 @09:47PM
(#41703935)
I like to give analogies to those who think fluoridation is dangerous.
Why do you drink water at all? Don't you know they make nuclear bombs out of hydrogen? Why are you willing to consume nuclear fuel?
Re:How a California county got PFAS out of its drinking water
by yencabulator on Tuesday October 01, 2024 @12:16PM
(#41710446)
Meanwhile, every US dentist I see is amazed at my teeth (middle-aged with no cavities) and asks if they use fluoride where I'm from (yes they do).