News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California bans legacy admissions at private universities by dgacmu on Monday September 30, 2024 @02:51PM (#41700609)
I found myself wondering how in the world they'd actually manage this and not be violating the universities' 1st amendment rights, and the answer seems to be:

> Republicans as well as Democrats in the California Legislature voted for Mr. Ting’s latest proposal, which will punish institutions that flout the law by publishing their names on a California Department of Justice website.

and from the latimes report:

> Although the California law makes legacy and donor admissions illegal, it does not specify any punishment for universities that violate it.

Which answers the question but certainly raises some questions of what it means for something to be "illegal" with no actual consequences.

Re:California bans legacy admissions at private universities by JumpCrisscross on Monday September 30, 2024 @03:19PM (#41700958)
Admittance isn't speech. (There might be an argument for assembly. But we already have precedence in e.g. the Civil Rights Acts that it can be regulated.)
Re:California bans legacy admissions at private universities by dgacmu on Monday September 30, 2024 @03:43PM (#41701241)
I agree, I should have said 1st amendment rights more generally. I've edited my post to update that - thank you.
Re:California bans legacy admissions at private universities by vineyardmike on Monday September 30, 2024 @03:43PM (#41701237)
It absolutely is assembly.

Also, "businesses" have the right to pick their customers (in compliance with laws like fair housing).

I don't have a strong preference for/against legacy admissions, but I think that saying "we can admit only people of religion X" is ok but its wrong to say "we can admit people preferentially who have a family connection". Same with affirmative action vs race-based admissions.

There are so many sticky issues with the legality and meritocracy of admissions, that targeting a few rich kids seems like the wrong battle.

Re:California bans legacy admissions at private universities by snickerbockers on Monday September 30, 2024 @03:05PM (#41700783)
>I found myself wondering how in the world they'd actually manage this and not be violating the universities' free speech

One of the primary justifications I keep hearing for Affirmative Action is that legacy admissions are predominantly white, so minorities need an extra edge in non-legacy admissions to balance out the race quotas. If we take this to be true and assume that Affirmative Action is off the table then naturally it's necessary to eliminate legacy admissions.

Of course, you're right that there's no real point in enacting laws if they aren't going to punish institutions who violate them.

Re:California bans legacy admissions at private universities by jjmarr on Monday September 30, 2024 @03:42PM (#41701230)
There's still a non-zero cost for compliance because universities have to report their legacy statistics.
Re:California bans legacy admissions at private universities by scarface_74 on Monday September 30, 2024 @03:12PM (#41700845)
Well, how is legacy admissions free speech and affirmative action “prejudice” and illegal according to the Supreme Court? Neither is based on merit alone.

No I am not arguing for or against affirmative action in college admissions. I am Black and graduated from an HBCU. I haven’t had a reason to think about affirmative action deeply enough to have an informed opinion.

Re:California bans legacy admissions at private universities by Manuel_D on Monday September 30, 2024 @03:31PM (#41701110)
Race is a protected class. Wealth is not. A bank can require a certain amount of money to be deposited in a checking account to qualify for certain cards and benefits. They can't just say "this card is for X race only".
Re:California bans legacy admissions at private universities by scarface_74 on Monday September 30, 2024 @04:02PM (#41701448)
Fine. If it’s not in the public interest. A “private” college shouldn’t be eligible for federal financial aid, tax exempt status, etc just like a bank isn’t. We should tax earnings from their endowments too
Re:California bans legacy admissions at private universities by Manuel_D on Monday September 30, 2024 @04:07PM (#41701499)
"Public interest" isn't an excuse to strip tax exempt status or withhold funding on a whim. The government cannot simply remove the tax exempt status of the NRA or Planned Parenthood because it decides that the organization doesn't serve public interest.
Re:California bans legacy admissions at private universities by Supermancho on Monday September 30, 2024 @04:36PM (#41701811)
> The government cannot simply remove the tax exempt status of the NRA or Planned Parenthood because it decides that the organization doesn't serve public interest.

The (aggregate) government is the only one who can, as it's the only one who granted the status. The idea that something is ironclad because it's enshrined in law, is a failing to consider history. Laws change.

If you want to argue that it's unlikely, this also depends largely on those who have the money (or power) to fight for the change. I would agree there is not enough public sentiment, despite the wealth inequality implications, for private universities. Planned Parenthood? I think we got awful close.

Either way, it could be done. It is important not to dismiss the possibility.

Re:California bans legacy admissions at private universities by Manuel_D on Monday September 30, 2024 @04:42PM (#41701855)
Stanford alone has an endowment upwards of 30 billion dollars. They absolutely have the resources to fight the change.
Re:California bans legacy admissions at private universities by caraig on Monday September 30, 2024 @07:24PM (#41703161)
There are specific laws about university endowments and how they can be spent. There isn't a single vault full of money called 'The Endowment.' It's thousands and thousands of buckets, each earmarked for specific purposes, usually invested so that the university can function off the investment of the endowment monies, instead of the endowment itself. But even so, many if not most of those buckets cannot legally be spent. Stanford can't reach into 'the endowment' and throw money at a problem.
Re:California bans legacy admissions at private universities by Manuel_D on Monday September 30, 2024 @11:04PM (#41704284)
Yes, university donors often give grants to specific programs and initiatives. And those very same donors are the ones that have the biggest stake in preserving legacy admissions. They'd have zero issues funding a legal defense of legacy admissions.
Re:California bans legacy admissions at private universities by scarface_74 on Monday September 30, 2024 @07:40PM (#41703271)
The NRA also doesn’t get public subsidies from the government in the form of student loans nor is their membership exclusive. Anyone can join the NRA and anyone can walk into planned parenthood

And if you want to compare it to a bank - a bank pays taxes

Re:California bans legacy admissions at private universities by dgacmu on Monday September 30, 2024 @03:26PM (#41701053)
Don't get me wrong: I think legacy admissions should be eliminated. And my understanding is that my university (Carnegie Mellon) has stopped considering legacy status as part of admissions.

But the answer is that legacy is a one-hop removed racial bias instead of a direct one, where the schools engaging in it can claim that it's based on a purely financial incentive and that it applies equally to all of their legacies. It's like money laundering for bias: Finding a proxy metric that happens to correlate extremely well with race but never explicitly mentions it. With the current supreme court, that laundering seems kinda likely to succeed.

Re:California bans legacy admissions at private universities by dmayle on Monday September 30, 2024 @04:03PM (#41701458)
You actually have it backwards. Your claim is that legacy admissions bias in favor of the predominant race might be true for a school that had race-blind admittance criteria. In the opposite case, however, legacy admissions bias against people of the predominant race (for the general student).

Since legacy admissions come first, schools which practice affirmative action have a heavy bias against the predominant race (because those slots are all filled by legacy candidate). Which means that if you're of the predominant race, you have next to no chance to be accepted by these universities... (I mean, everyone has next to no chance, but for people of the predominant race, they are discriminated against severely).

In general, though, college admissions are pretty terrible... Having spoken with someone who worked in admissions at one of these universities, if you have a bright kid, you're better off moving to the middle of nowhere to make sure they're the valedictorian, rather than trying to send your kid to a great high school where why might only be salutatorian. Why? For smaller schools they rarely take more than one student from that school in any given year, so when the valedictorian who filled out applications to 10 top schools gets in to all 10? The salutatorian doesn't...

Re:California bans legacy admissions at private universities by scarface_74 on Monday September 30, 2024 @07:43PM (#41703286)
The Supreme Court made race illegal as a requirement for admission.
Re:California bans legacy admissions at private universities by scarface_74 on Monday September 30, 2024 @04:04PM (#41701469)
Re:California bans legacy admissions at private universities by dgacmu on Monday September 30, 2024 @04:18PM (#41701628)
Hence my comment that "With the current supreme court, that laundering seems kinda likely to succeed."

I don't disagree with anything you're arguing from a moral perspective. I'm not a big fan of what's happening at the supreme court these days.

We may get to find out: https://www.npr.org/2023/07/26/1190123323/department-of-educ...

Re:California bans legacy admissions at private universities by Spivak on Monday September 30, 2024 @03:02PM (#41700752)
There's plenty of laws like that. They're a statement about what someone oughtn't do in the hopes that people follow it simply because it's the law. I think it's a good solution to the situations where we want to establish a norm but it's beyond the scope of government to enforce it.

Assuming laws require enforcement is the secular version of "if you're an atheist and don't fear eternal punishment in hell, why are you good?"

Re:California bans legacy admissions at private universities by winwang on Monday September 30, 2024 @03:16PM (#41700917)
Isn't this confounding legality and morality? But I do agree with the idea of trying to establish a norm somehow, since legality is a decent proxy.
Re:California bans legacy admissions at private universities by jjmarr on Monday September 30, 2024 @03:41PM (#41701216)
The legal system is partly the codification of society's views on what constitutes unethical behaviour. Specifically, things that harm society as a whole.

Making an action against the law expresses a very strong disapproval of that action.

Re:California bans legacy admissions at private universities by tourmalinetaco on Monday September 30, 2024 @03:33PM (#41701123)
Well, most laws are made on moral principles.