News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nexus 7, Made for Google Play by jamesaguilar on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @06:50PM (#4169588)
> Your Windows OEM analogy does not hold since the OEM does not develop nor integrate their own version of Windows.

For the most part, the extent of this with Android is providing drivers and firmware for an individual phone's hardware, plus a few crapware apps to run on the desktop. This happens all the time in the Windows ecosystem too. I think the analogy is holding up just fine.

I am argumentative, so it is reasonable for me to come off this way, although you're right that I should chill a little. I dislike the double standards that people have with respect to Google and other companies on this subject.

Re:Nexus 7, Made for Google Play by wvenable on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @06:54PM (#4169601)
But, of course, you're wrong since there is no double-standard. Microsoft is no more responsible than Google is with regards to their software installed on hardware you buy from a manufacturer.
Re:Nexus 7, Made for Google Play by jamesaguilar on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @07:00PM (#4169634)
I would be very surprised if the average Joe feels this way. To double check my theories, I just asked three engineers where I work and they all seem to believe that Microsoft has an obligation to support new, high-end laptops in a near-term OS bump.
Re:Nexus 7, Made for Google Play by wvenable on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @07:03PM (#4169646)
Microsoft has no such obligation; but you might certainly want that. But we all want stuff. Do a bunch of engineers want Microsoft to release an OS that supports their new laptops -- of course. So what.

The thing is, this happens all the time. My Dell laptop came with Vista and it doesn't "support" Windows 7. You can't get 7 drivers directly from them. It runs 7 just fine (in fact better) but you're on your own to get it working.

Re:Nexus 7, Made for Google Play by jamesaguilar on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @07:10PM (#4169676)
> Microsoft has no such obligation

You and I are using different meanings of this word. Presumably you are referring to a legal obligation, or a moral one. I don't recognize the existence of morality and I suspect that, unless they have a "Windows 8 Ready" tag on the machine, no legal obligation would exist either.

The "obligation" I am speaking of is an expectation formed in the minds of average consumers to the point where they consider it a fault on the part of the software manufacturer when the expectation is not met.

> Dell ...

How old was the machine? There's a big difference in most consumers' expectations between failing to support N-year old devices and devices that are currently selling.

Re:Nexus 7, Made for Google Play by wvenable on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @07:19PM (#4169702)
> The "obligation" I am speaking of is an expectation...

Obligation is a legal or moral term -- you can't use that term otherwise. An expectation is not an obligation. If you expect free cookies from me because I've been giving you free cookies every day for the past week, that's fine. But I'm not obligated to give you free cookies today. If Bob gives you free cookies and I'm now sitting in Bob's desk, you might expect free cookies but I'm not obligated to give them to you.

Microsoft provides updates out of the goodness of their heart. You might expect them to continue giving updates forever. They're not obligated to do that. And because they give updates, Google isn't obligated to do it too.

If you'd like your expectations to be met, find Bob and he might give you some cookies.

Re:Nexus 7, Made for Google Play by jamesaguilar on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @07:31PM (#4169737)
I guess we have reached an impasse. We'll see how well this approach works out for Google in the long run. I'm inclined to suspect it is hurting them as it would probably hurt Microsoft if they started breaking backwards compatibility with every OS release. But reality will have to be the arbiter of whether this theory is correct.

Also, IMO, the term social obligation is pretty well understood. It's an expectation of your behavior by others.

Re:Nexus 7, Made for Google Play by wslh on Thursday June 28, 2012 @01:07AM (#4170418)
I loved this thread. I am beginning to hate Google. I don't care about words and explanations: I remember updating my iPhone "1" a little while after the Apple event, While just updating my Samsung Galaxi SII to ICS a few weeks ago with shitty Movistar stuff bundled and where they even removed the "native" browser and you must go to the search option tocopen it. Sure I can now install Chrome but I discovered that Opera works better than Firefox and Chrome! (hilarious? I can't submit to HN with these last two). And everyday I trigger vlingo shit because I pressed two times the home button and can't be disabled! (vlingo posted a solution that don't work on their websites).

I don't want a Ferrari that is not leaving its potential.

Re:Nexus 7, Made for Google Play by wvenable on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @07:41PM (#4169777)
> We'll see how well this approach works out for Google in the long run.

You make it seem like Google want this but I seriously doubt that they do. They simply don't have any say in the matter. They gave the carriers and the manufacturers everything they wanted to get into the market and now they can't close the barn door after the horses have run out. So instead they have their Nexus devices.

> social obligation is pretty well understood

Social obligation is also a moral term and it means more than just doing what people expect you to do because they are spoiled.

Re:Nexus 7, Made for Google Play by Bjartr on Thursday June 28, 2012 @01:01AM (#4170402)
Do you believe that Google doesn't want all Android users to have the latest and greatest? The more people happy with Android, the more people using Android, the more people seeing Google provided ads, which was the whole point of starting Android in the first place.