Re:US Trademark Office Cancels Marvel, DC's 'Super Hero' Marks
by acdha on Monday September 30, 2024 @08:25AM
(#41696360)
> I pointed out that that wouldn't be relevant, and you're agreeing with that here. What kind of "correction" is this?
It’s the kind where multiple people are trying to help you understand something. Trademarks are intended to avoid confusion in the marketplace, so my point was that later shifting ownership to a different organization doesn’t change the question. They’d still be asking whether consumers think of the term as specific or generic because consumers rarely care about the distinction between a company and an organization controlled by that company.
Here's your earlier comment:
>> it’d be trivial to show that usage of the term predated that organization by decades
I pointed out that that wouldn't be relevant, and you're agreeing with that here. What kind of "correction" is this?
Assume, as you do, that "super hero" was originally in common use to refer to any benevolent character with supernatural abilities, and over time, subsequent to the grant of the trademark, it specialized to the point that the public now understands it only to refer to characters owned by DC or Marvel.
That would tell us that (1) as a historical matter, the trademark was improperly granted; and (2) as a legal matter, the trademark is currently valid. The preexisting use doesn't matter to anyone. The current meaning of the term matters.