News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gavin Newsom vetoes SB 1047 by crazygringo on Sunday September 29, 2024 @09:13PM (#41692452)
> impossibly vague for a piece of legislation - "reasonable care" and "unreasonable risk" sound like things that could be endlessly litigated.

Nope, that's entirely standard legal stuff. Tort law deals exactly with those kinds of things, for instance. Yes it can certainly wind up in litigation, but the entire point is that if there's a gray area, a company should make sure it's operating entirely within the OK area -- or know it's taking a legal gamble if it tries to push the envelope.

But it's generally pretty easy to stay in the clear if you establish common-sense processes around these things, with a clear paper trail and decisions approved by lawyers.

Now the legislation can be bad for lots of other reasons, but "reasonable care" and "unreasonable risk" are not problematic.

Re:Gavin Newsom vetoes SB 1047 by hn_throwaway_99 on Sunday September 29, 2024 @09:45PM (#41692662)
> but "reasonable care" and "unreasonable risk" are not problematic.

Still strongly disagree, at least when it comes to AI legislation. Yes, I fully realize that there are "reasonableness" standards in lots of places of US jurisprudence, but when it comes to AI, given how new the tech is and how, perhaps more than any other recent technology, it is largely a "black box", meaning we don't really know how it works and we aren't really sure what its capabilities will ultimately be, I don't think anybody really knows what "reasonableness" means in this context.

Re:Gavin Newsom vetoes SB 1047 by razakel on Monday September 30, 2024 @06:40AM (#41695627)
Exactly. It's about as meaningful as passing a law making it illegal to be a criminal. Right, so what does that actually mean apart from "we'll decide when it happens"?