Similarly here, if there is a formula that stupid being used, even as a memory aid, it suggests to me that real lives could be saved if they embed a few real Ops Research specialists somewhere important instead of whatever they are doing.
Assuming that you can never make anybody worse off than they were before you showed up would be a much worse abuse.
I mean try defining waste and quality.
Fundamentally, and to use a non-mathematical term appropriately in context, it is a load of bollocks. It is used to make simple ideas look like they are rigorously defined to people without the tools to interpret them. And that is dishonest.
As for inappropriate statistical methods, survey companies are a breeding ground for providing tools which the results of are not interpreted with any statistical rigour or language.
Source: annoyed mathematician.
One of the few comments on HN i fully agree with without reservation :-)
While folks may use symbols instead of long-winded statements they need to make it clear that it is merely a shorthand and no mathematical rigour is implied.
It may be best, I agree, but it's not what people do. I've seen enough people with advanced degrees take things like FMEA risk priority numbers or adding up the numbers in a Pugh matrix very literally, not as a basis for discussion and insight.
>The children who used to whine about, 'When are we every going to use this?' grow up to be adults who complain about not having learnt about how to complete their tax returns at school.
I've seen my former classmates complain on Facebook about not having been taught things ("there should be a class in high school!") that were absolutely taught in the dumb state required classes.
No, the purpose of putting this into an "equation" is to imply false rigor, and simultaneously to imply that you should hire our people to implement our "healthcare quality framework". I mean, would people really think this is any sort of non-obvious advice if you simply stated, "To improve quality, you should improve appropriateness of treatments, improve outcomes and improve service, and reduce waste." I mean, no shit Sherlock. But once you put it into an "equation", you're deliberately, and falsely, implying "Oooh, science!"
I think it's best to think of this as an overextended metaphor, rather than a clumsy attempt to provide a rigorous relationship. The message to take away from this 'equation' is:
* more appropriateness means more quality; * better outcomes means more quality; * better service means more quality; * less waste means more quality.
It's a small minority of people who give a shit about mathematics. The children who used to whine about, 'When are we every going to use this?' grow up to be adults who complain about not having learnt about how to complete their tax returns at school.
The equation above is an aide de memoire for people managing healthcare facilities. It's irrelevant to people who understand that it's an abuse of mathematical ideas.
The 'Fixing mathiness' section, however, is very good. This article is from a survey company, so this is about increasing the validity of the results you get from their product, but it speaks to the problem of inappropriate statistical methods being used to manufacture signals from noise.