Re:TinyPNG: Lossy compression for PNG that preserves full tr...
by trebor on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @01:49PM
(#4168114)
Ditto. I'd like to see some side-by-side comparisons with PNGOUT, PNGCrush, OptiPNG, and AdvPNG. I use ImageOptim on my Mac to automate my PNG optimization—and it can get some impressive gains.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:TinyPNG: Lossy compression for PNG that preserves full tr...
by kizza on Thursday June 28, 2012 @03:34AM
(#4170665)
On the Mac I use ImageAlpha to reduce the colours to 256 (it has a preview window so you can see if it's OK), then when saving the file I choose the option to send it to ImageOptim.
On Linux you can get the same by using pngquant, then using trimage. AFAIK there's no GUI frontend for pngquant so I guess how many colours would be ok and check before running trimage.
The reason why I use 2 tools is that ImageAlpha/pngquant is lossy and ImageOptim/trimage is lossless.
Re:TinyPNG: Lossy compression for PNG that preserves full tr...
by eli on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @02:17PM
(#4168291)
I think ImageOptim uses the pngcrush library.
This website looks neat, but it seems like a CLI that can become part of my automated workflow would generally be more useful.
Re:TinyPNG: Lossy compression for PNG that preserves full tr...
by molf on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @03:15PM
(#4168692)
The tools you mention use lossless compression. For 24-bit PNG files that means they probably won't come close the kind of lossy compression used by TinyPNG.
Re:TinyPNG: Lossy compression for PNG that preserves full tr...
by trebor on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @06:19PM
(#4169487)
The comparison will be subjective. One will retain full detail (24-bit color) and the other will not. The "better" will be subjective, as I said.
I wish Photoshop gave the option to save an 8-bit PNG with a FULL alpha channel—that's what this seems to do.