News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Everything we know about spies is wrong by red_admiral on Friday September 27, 2024 @10:22AM (#41670861)
This is pure gold, and still works on the internet to get the specs for PLA tanks:

> If she wants to know something specific, but doesn’t want people to notice her asking questions, she should simply make incorrect statements while in the company of experts. Her companions will correct her, especially if they’re men.

Re:Everything we know about spies is wrong by praptak on Friday September 27, 2024 @10:47AM (#41671162)
I heard this one about Linux in the '90s. "If you need help with doing something in Linux, don't ask for help - you'll get ignored. Just boldly state Linux can't do that and you'll have PhDs running to prove you wrong."
Re:Everything we know about spies is wrong by neilv on Friday September 27, 2024 @11:38AM (#41671821)
Related, around 2000, knowing which hardware device to buy for any/good Linux compatibility could be difficult.

And even among supported devices, some had better drivers (currently, or imminently), and some hardware itself was buggier than others.

I had access to some kernel developers, but they didn't have time for people's FAQs about current device compatibility.

So what I really did do, at least once, was to narrow down the options on my own, and then (lying) mention, in the enthusiastic manner that people did, that I'd just ordered such-and-such device for Linux.

As you'd guess, but it was still impressive to see happen for real, suddenly there were a number of experts telling me what I should've bought instead.

Question answered. I then admitted my deceit.

Re:Everything we know about spies is wrong by bonestamp2 on Friday September 27, 2024 @11:03AM (#41671345)
It works on hacker news and reddit too, for almost any subject.
Re:Everything we know about spies is wrong by praptak on Friday September 27, 2024 @11:40AM (#41671867)
It also works in reverse, when checking someone's story with an untrusted third party (say a suspect's friend).

Ask them about the story with some facts wrong. If they don't correct you, the story is probably false and they are just confirming anything.

Re:Everything we know about spies is wrong by qazxcvbnmlp on Friday September 27, 2024 @11:39AM (#41671853)
The comments that get the most replies often have something slightly wrong and related to hot button topics for this audience.
Re:Everything we know about spies is wrong by NikkiA on Friday September 27, 2024 @12:38PM (#41672651)
AKA Cunningham's law, although it predates linux.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ward_Cunningham#Cunningham's_L...

Re:Everything we know about spies is wrong by like_any_other on Friday September 27, 2024 @11:31AM (#41671724)
> Her companions will correct her, especially if they’re men.

Observe the importance of phrasing. If this had been put as "men enjoy sharing knowledge, while women are content to let others wallow in ignorance and error", it would have ruffled a great many more feathers.

Re:Everything we know about spies is wrong by poincaredisk on Friday September 27, 2024 @12:12PM (#41672344)
It seems to me that the current phrasing ruffled your feathers. (As it did mine, since I'm not sure this is a gendered phenomenon, but the fact is that your version would make me feel better - contray to your thesis).
Re:Everything we know about spies is wrong by praptak on Friday September 27, 2024 @11:46AM (#41671959)
Sticking to facts ruffles less feathers than adding a charged interpretation to the facts, it's not very surprising.

("X is more likely to correct you" can obviously also have a negatively charged interpretation, which I'm leaving as an exercise to the reader)

Re:Everything we know about spies is wrong by like_any_other on Friday September 27, 2024 @12:28PM (#41672526)
I suppose you're right - to highlight the implied, or shall we say, permitted interpretation, I was forced to give a contrasting interpretation, when the source text was indeed purely factual.
Re:Everything we know about spies is wrong by itronitron on Friday September 27, 2024 @12:40PM (#41672673)
X may be more likely to correct you simply because there are more of them, which is different from saying that someone is more likely to correct you "especially if they are X"
Re:Everything we know about spies is wrong by red_admiral on Saturday September 28, 2024 @08:31AM (#41679823)
The alternative phrasing would not, IMHO, have been true. If someone genuinely claimed that, then entirely in the spirit of the original quote, lots of people would chime in.
Re:Everything we know about spies is wrong by rramadass on Friday September 27, 2024 @11:07AM (#41671389)
Re:Everything we know about spies is wrong by ffujdefvjg on Friday September 27, 2024 @11:46AM (#41671967)
You can also use this to get a rough idea of who the most insecure people in the room are and work from there.
Re:Everything we know about spies is wrong by poincaredisk on Friday September 27, 2024 @12:15PM (#41672390)
What's wrong with correcting someone? It requires some effort from the person doing the correcting, but it facilitates information sharing and lends itself to a more productive environment. If course it can be done in an shooting way, especially if the correcter is a jerk, but most people aren't.
Re:Everything we know about spies is wrong by dfxm12 on Friday September 27, 2024 @12:44PM (#41672726)
Depends on the context. Correcting impertinent details comes off as pedantic and detracts from the conversation at hand. Like, if you and your partner are talking about how delicious your meal at a restaurant was with another couple, it's not worth correcting your partner over the name of server, or if they got the price wrong by a few bucks. Maybe it's worth correcting your partner if they say you got the halibut when you got the salmon though.
Re:Everything we know about spies is wrong by seba_dos1 on Saturday September 28, 2024 @01:54AM (#41678198)
This is absurd. If I mention the name of the server or the price it's because it's supposed to mean something to what I'm saying, as otherwise I wouldn't be mentioning those things at all. If I get them wrong, I would surely appreciate my partner correcting me.

Correcting typos when everyone can see what was supposed to be there may be pedantic as it serves no communication value, but correcting facts?

Re:Everything we know about spies is wrong by psd1 on Saturday September 28, 2024 @02:45PM (#41682179)
You have a narrow view on people's reasons for speaking.

My sisters-in-law speak because, if their jaws stop moving for a few minutes, they will suffocate and die. Persiflage is uttered that has no bearing on anything else said.

Re:Everything we know about spies is wrong by seba_dos1 on Sunday September 29, 2024 @02:57AM (#41685419)
I don't think "some people out there spill a lot of non-sense out of their mouths" is a valid argument against correcting facts; if anything, it may be an argument for trying to avoid such people if possible.