News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I Am Tired of AI by layer8 on Friday September 27, 2024 @07:16AM (#41668971)
> I can spend my time revieweing and correcting.

Do you really like spending most of your time reviewing AI output? I certainly don’t, that’s soul-crushing.

Re:I Am Tired of AI by sgu999 on Friday September 27, 2024 @08:02AM (#41669374)
Not much more than reviewing the code of any average dev who doesn't bother doing their due diligence. At least with an AI I immediately get an answer with "Oh yes, you're right, sorry for the oversight" and a fix. Instead of some bullshit explanation to try to convince me that their crappy code is following the specs and has no issues.

That said, I'm deeply saddened by the fact that I won't be passing on a craft I spent two decades refining.

Re:I Am Tired of AI by koliber on Friday September 27, 2024 @07:57AM (#41669328)
That's essentially what many hands-on engineering managers or staff engineers do today. They spend significant portions of their day reviewing code from more junior team members.

Reviewing and modifying code is more engaging than typing out the solution that is fully formed in my head. If the AI creates something close to what I have in my head from the description I gave it, I can work with it to get it even closer. I can also hand-edit it.

Re:I Am Tired of AI by woah on Friday September 27, 2024 @11:59AM (#41672146)
I think there are two types of developers: those who are most excited about building things, and those who are most excited about the craft of programming.

If I can build things faster, then I'm happy to spend most of my time reviewing AI code. That doesn't mean that I never write code. Some things the AI is worse at, or need to be exactly write and its faster to do them manually.

Re:I Am Tired of AI by samcat116 on Friday September 27, 2024 @05:27PM (#41675704)
I think we could see a lot of these AI code tools start to pivot towards product folks for just this reason. They aren't meant for the people who find craft in what they do.
Re:I Am Tired of AI by koliber on Saturday September 28, 2024 @08:17AM (#41679770)
> I think there are two types of developers: those who are most excited about building things, and those who are most excited about the craft of programming.

Love this. You hit the nail right on the head.

I don't know if I fit into one or the other. However, I do know that at times I feel like one, and at other times, the other.

If I am writing another new app and need to build a slew of CRUD code, I don't care about the craft. I mean, I don't want sloppy code, but I do not get joy out of writing what is _almost_ boilerplate. I still want it to reflect my style, but I don't want to type it all out. I already know how it all works in my head. The faster I get it into an IDE the better. Cursor (the AI IDE) allowed me to do this much faster than I would have by hand.

Then there is time where I do want to craft something beautiful. I had one part of this project where I needed to build a scheduler and I had very specific things I wanted it to do. I tried twice to describe what I want but the AI tool did not do what I wanted. It built a working piece of code, but I could not get it to grasp the nuance.

I sat down and wrote the code for the scheduler, but then had to deal with a bunch of edge cases. I took this code, gave it to the AI and told it to implement those edge cases. After reviewing and iterating on it, I had exactly what I wanted.