News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Ruby is an acceptable Lisp (2005) by olavk on Thursday January 01, 2009 @03:45PM (#416664)
I don't see how Ruby could be called a Lisp. To me, the fundamental concept of Lisp is that the basic data structure is the cons-pair, and that both code and data can be represented and manipulated as graphs of cons-pairs.

The blog is arguing that Ruby is an acceptable alternative to Lisp, which may be true. But that doesn't make Ruby a Lisp.

Re:Why Ruby is an acceptable Lisp (2005) by erso on Thursday January 01, 2009 @04:22PM (#416690)
The crux of the post seems to be that because Ruby has lambdas, it is an acceptable alternative.

In my experience, being that I'm learning Haskell and coming from a Ruby background, merely having lambdas doesn't qualify for functional status.

Re:Why Ruby is an acceptable Lisp (2005) by Maascamp on Thursday January 01, 2009 @04:42PM (#416695)
Well said. The latest version of PHP is going to have lambdas, and I'm quite certain that it's not a Lisp.
Re:Why Ruby is an acceptable Lisp (2005) by jrockway on Friday January 02, 2009 @09:59AM (#417353)
Its lambdas don't even close over lexical state, so I'm not sure why they even exist. Yet another concept the PHP designers don't get, I guess, but feel pressured to add. (See also: PHP's object system.)
Re:Why Ruby is an acceptable Lisp (2005) by neeson on Thursday January 01, 2009 @08:02PM (#416854)
Interestingly enough, one of Clojure's selling points is that the basic data structure is not the cons-pair (rather the implementation details of storage are abstracted). It is clearly a lisp, however.
Re:Why Ruby is an acceptable Lisp (2005) by thisisnotmyname on Thursday January 01, 2009 @06:05PM (#416768)
He's not arguing that ruby is a Lisp, just that it gives most of the power of Lisp in a syntax closer to what most programmers are familiar with.
Re:Why Ruby is an acceptable Lisp (2005) by Jebdm on Friday January 02, 2009 @01:00AM (#417110)
You're right, but he shouldn't have titled it "Why Ruby is an acceptable Lisp".