News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:OpenAI to Become For-Profit Company by mlinsey on Thursday September 26, 2024 @02:12PM (#41661407)
I haven't seen any details, but isn't this a pretty straightforward way of doing it? The non-profit has had majority ownership of the for-profit subsidiary since 2019. The already-for-profit subsidiary has owned all the ChatGPT IP, all the recent models, all the employee relationships, etc etc.

The cleanest way for this to work is the for-profit to just sell more shares at the $150B valuation, diluting the non-profit entity below majority ownership. The for-profit board, which the non-profit could still probably have multiple seats on, would control the real asset, the non-profit would still exist and hold many tens of billions of value. It could further sell its shares in the non-profit and use the proceeds in a way consistent with its mission.

They wouldn't even have to sell that much - I am pretty sure the mega-fundrasing rounds from Microsoft etc brought the non-profit's ownership to just north of 50% anyway.

I don't see how this wouldn't be above board, it's how I assumed it was going to work. It would indeed mean that the entity that controls ChatGPT would now be answerable to shareholders, a majority of which would be profit seeking and a minority of which would be the non-profit with its mission, but non-profits are allowed to invest in for-profits and then sell those shares; all the calls for prosecutions etc seems just like an internet pitchfork mob to me.

Re:OpenAI to Become For-Profit Company by jprete on Thursday September 26, 2024 @02:30PM (#41661596)
The non-profit would have to approve the scheme, and a rational non-profit would not, because it gives up any ability the non-profit has to fulfill its charter.
Re:OpenAI to Become For-Profit Company by space_fountain on Thursday September 26, 2024 @02:38PM (#41661675)
Exactly, the question is this move in the non profits best interests? It's definitely in the best interest of the people running the non profit but I think many of the early donors wouldn't feel like this was what they were signing up for
Re:OpenAI to Become For-Profit Company by space_fountain on Thursday September 26, 2024 @02:31PM (#41661616)
I think the problem is early employees and investors were convinced to invest their time and money into a non profit. They were told that one of the reasons they should donate/work there as opposed to Google was because they were a non profit focused on doing good. Now when it seems like that non profit is successful that all is being thrown out the window in service of a structure that will result in more profit for the people running the non profit