I agree that singlehoming to a good tier-2 provider is much better than being singlehomed to a tier-1 of any quality; It's not so much the support I fear as the... as you said, depeering.
(of course, if you are looking for and willing to pay for serious bandwidth, you want to look for three or more upstreams. And in that case, having 3 tier 1 providers is better than having 3 tier 2 providers, as you are less likely to get route overlap, and tier 1 providers, all other things being equal, usually have better latency.)
Being single homed to a small but competent provider who is multihomed is IMO better than being single homed to a large provider, in that the small provider is a lot more likely to actually help you out when things go wrong.
Cogent obviously would be a nice way to get some cheap extra bandwidth, too. I just fear depeering days :)