Thats not the point I am making. I think you people can make a case for expenses without conflating them with economic investment. A swing set might not make money, but I can play with my kids there and have fun. I can buy a beer without it being an investment.

I dont think I agree with the velocity of money argument. It wouldnt be stagnating under some mattress. However, that is a much bigger topic that I dont think Im up for today