News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gene Sharp: A dictator's worst nightmare by gruseom on Tuesday June 26, 2012 @08:14PM (#4164873)
Of course I don't mean that nonviolence beats violence every time (edit: though in fairness I do see what sounded like that). That would be magic fairy dust. The point about Gandhi is that what he did worked at all.

Power accumulates in the hands of whoever controls large numbers of men with guns.

If you're right, why would the military take Sharp seriously, as the article says they do? Don't they have all the guns?

The few times that nonviolent movements have succeeded, they have done so against a tired power

That smells like hindsight bias to me: if it works, the regime must have been "tired".

Re:Gene Sharp: A dictator's worst nightmare by flyinRyan on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @08:04AM (#4166498)
Well I personally contend that it's never worked at all. Do you have any specific examples?
Re:Gene Sharp: A dictator's worst nightmare by gruseom on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @02:32PM (#4168390)
Given that you credit Martin Luther King's success not to nonviolence but to the Black Panthers, who didn't even exist until 1966, I believe no example will convince you.

This is one of the low points of a thread with a lot of low points. I regret posting the article. It was borderline to begin with (political, but intellectually interesting), but the toxicity of the discussion it immediately gave rise to shows that I made the wrong call. It's not just that it's toxic, it's atypically toxic – significantly more malignant than usual. HN has enough local species of weeds to tend to; this is like an ecological invasion (or would be if it got out of hand).

Edit: a more positive spin is that this is a good limit case showing that the guidelines are about right.

Re:Gene Sharp: A dictator's worst nightmare by flyinRyan on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @03:30PM (#4168787)
I was quoting from memory. So it wasn't the Black Panthers but there was targeted violence going on. Of course if you're going to give in you want to give credit to someone like Martin Luther King so hopefully in future people will imagine that non-violence works and you can be safe to ignore them.

It was certainly wrong of you to try and forward the propaganda machine of claiming the nonviolence on its own is an effective mechanism against dictatorships. None of us want violence, but many of us don't want lies either.

Re:Gene Sharp: A dictator's worst nightmare by ScottBurson on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @06:01PM (#4169438)
I'm very glad you posted it, as I don't know if I would have heard of Gene Sharp any other way.

The fractiousness of the discussion is unfortunate, but nobody has to read it.

Re:Gene Sharp: A dictator's worst nightmare by gruseom on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @06:36PM (#4169539)
Thanks for saying so. I'm glad I peeked back in here and saw it. Yes, Sharp is genuinely interesting.