FYI, Standard Oil was never actually charged with market manipulation. The court determined that all of their acquisitions were legal, but that it was within the scope of the Sherman Antitrust Act to break them up just by virtue of their market power.
https://www.lendingtree.com/credit-cards/articles/na-vs-eu-i...
Grandparent commenter was engaging in a false dilemma fallacy (cash handling vs US merchant cc fees...and not US merchant CC fees vs what the rest of the world pays.)
I looked through the lawsuit and this is about stifling alternative payment methods.
The issue isn't the solution, the issue is the staggering cost of the service in the US vs everywhere else. It's 2x higher in the US, for no good reason other than having a monopoly. In Europe near-instant wiring of money is trivial so for large purchases, businesses can just accept a transfer - so MC/Visa have competition there.
Here, wire transfers are a royal pain in the ass, slow, and expensive, so there's no competition. Zelle and others are slowly changing that, but they mostly compete against paypal for p2p payments, not b2c etc.
There doesn't need to be a magical new business here. Some numbers changing can resolve a lot of pressure.
>Visa charges 3%. Everything you buy could be 3% cheaper, that's better than cash back.
>And anyone that ever uses cash for anything is overpaying, because prices everywhere have been jacked up to include headroom for "give back 2.5% as credit card rewards"
>For people like me who treat a credit card as a debit card, I see no reason for vendors to pay that "tax" if there are almost free alternatives.
Buying from Standard Oil was more efficient than trying to stick with non-oil-based alternatives, but that doesn't mean that Standard Oil didn't illegally manipulate the market to maintain a monopoly that hurt consumers.