News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google & Stanford create a digital brain that learns to i... by Retric on Tuesday June 26, 2012 @04:48PM (#4164021)
Let's say you want to build a robot that walks around like a person or even a goat. There are basically two part's of that problem, building the hardware, and building the software. If you use neural networks for the software then it's going to take more resources to run, and take a while to train. However, while people may be able to write more efficient software that requires fewer resources developing that software is going to take longer and cost a lot more money. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cNZPRsrwumQ

The idea that I can create software which works even if I don't understand why it works is a powerful idea. The point of AI as a field is stepping back and saying: "Computers are fast and cheap, people are slow and expensive, can't we automate this?" and continuing to do that not just to secretary's, or even coders, but also designers. As long as you can build a large enough training set and toss enough computing resources you can basically solve any problem.

Granted, the need for large training set's and processing power can also be a huge limitations. But, in the end neural nets / AI is just another tool like your computer, Algebra, or a big stick. The it's a cool idea and solves useful problems is enough for people to spend a lot of time and money looking into it.

Re:Google & Stanford create a digital brain that learns to i... by fghh45sdfhr3 on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @12:37PM (#4167794)
Granted, the need for large training set's and processing power can also be a huge limitations.

I think that is exactly what bothers me about it. It's that everything you say would be 100% correct IF we had far, far, far more computing resources at our disposal.

But since we don't, humans solving a problem actually does not take longer or cost more than training a neural net. Not if you want the neural net to be as good as the solution humans come up with.

Only if you are satisfied with a very quick and dirty approximation can NNs be faster and cheaper than humans.