An article on the demise of winamp suggested that the winamp people were receiving over $100,000 a month in checks sent by mail. I would suppose if you had an easier way to pay then checks by mail, even more "regular" people would be willing to pay.
I point out winamp because it is similar in that no new features are unlocked after paying.
Case in point: WinRAR, anyone?
EDIT: Just to clarify, I like the pricing model too. I just don't think it works for software in general.