Re:Jeff Geerling – They stole my voice with AI
by tikkun on Sunday September 22, 2024 @09:52AM
(#41617080)
I'll note that both photoshop and changing the timestamp of images (mentioned below) are only easy for a very small percentage of the population. It'd likely be different if >30% of people could easily do these things.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Jeff Geerling – They stole my voice with AI
by tga_d on Sunday September 22, 2024 @02:11PM
(#41618804)
Changing an image timestamp -- as in, exif metadata -- is trivially easy for anyone with a computer or phone, a quick search will tell you how to do it on any device with no skill involved. There's a difference between "easy for a small percentage of people" (modify the content of a photo in an undetectable way, find a software vulnerability, etc.) and "only a small percentage know how to do it" (modify exif values, do a simple magic trick, etc.). Just because someone doesn't know anyone can do it if they tried doesn't mean it's not trivial and pervasive.
Re:Jeff Geerling – They stole my voice with AI
by alexsmirnov on Sunday September 22, 2024 @10:53PM
(#41622036)
The problem that to make a right query, one has to know at least part of the answer. To search for exif modification tool, it's essential to understand:
- what is image file, and how information stored in it.
- the concept of `metadata`, and exif in particular.
- the concept that any file can be modified in place, or when you make a copy.
- know what where's ecosystem of open/free/custom tools that can do an unusual tasks.
The small percentage has all that knowledge at the hand to even get an idea of possibility to modify image timestamp
Re:Jeff Geerling – They stole my voice with AI
by shaftway on Monday September 23, 2024 @05:41PM
(#41630908)
This.
I'm currently the originator and lead on a project that will have huge impact on our bottom line. The team is mostly junior people, so when I presented the plan the response I got wasn't "I didn't think we could do that", it was "I didn't even know that that is a thing".
There used to be a joke about Rumsfeld's "known unknowns" vs. "unknown unknowns", but it's so true. And to the vast majority of people in the world the question isn't "how" to change a timestamp, it's understanding that a timestamp can even be changed.