News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Miraculous Resurrection of Notre-Dame by thegrim33 on Saturday September 21, 2024 @05:00PM (#41612640)
I mean you're entitled to your opinion but I'm not sure I can really understand this one. Should the Romans build a nice glass dome over the colosseum, maybe rebuild part of it with steel? What about the parthenon? I'm fine with building new stuff in new styles, but would rather we preserve historical works the best we can.
Re:The Miraculous Resurrection of Notre-Dame by ccppurcell on Saturday September 21, 2024 @05:24PM (#41612765)
I don't think it's obvious what it means to preserve historical works. A really clear example of my point is the Cerne Abbas Giant, a chalk figure on a hill in England. For a long time the idea was to try to leave it untouched. Adding chalk was seen as something like touching up the mona Lisa. But it was in danger of being lost and if memory serves it was discovered that when it was made people would refresh the chalk regularly. It's inherent to the work that it is maintained.

Let's say this giant is at one end of the spectrum, and the Mona Lisa is at the other. Its subjective where you place cathedrals, but certainly the builders intended it to be an operational building, and throughout its history there have been additions and modifications.

Re:The Miraculous Resurrection of Notre-Dame by BrandoElFollito on Saturday September 21, 2024 @05:35PM (#41612824)
Notre Dame had multiple accidents over the centuries. Every time something was rebuilt there was a war against changes. And yet many things changed - what you see is not what it looked like before the incident.

What exactly is different this time so that we do not leave a piece of contemporary history in Notre Dame?

Context: French, huge amateur of Middle Ages history.

Re:The Miraculous Resurrection of Notre-Dame by bigstrat2003 on Saturday September 21, 2024 @08:03PM (#41613566)
For one thing, the contemporary architecture of today sucks and the contemporary architecture of that day was actually good. It's very unlikely you would get a good result if you rebuilt the roof today.
Re:The Miraculous Resurrection of Notre-Dame by PetitPrince on Saturday September 21, 2024 @09:07PM (#41613838)
> the contemporary architecture of today sucks

Don't be so quick to judge your contemporaries, as today's turd may very well be tomorrow's jewel. The Eiffel Tower was considered a useless monstrosity back then, with many people (including famous authors, artists, and architects) opposing its construction.

Re:The Miraculous Resurrection of Notre-Dame by AStonesThrow on Sunday September 22, 2024 @02:44AM (#41615079)
Beauty is, in many respects, an objective quality, especially regarding colossal architecture. Geometry doesn't change. Perspective and proportion are enduring qualities, and all humankind hold these in common.

Furthermore, some architects and engineers are deliberately provoking ire by designing ugly and offensive structures. I mean, in what reality would someone enjoy having their eyes and senses brutalized by a Brutalist? It's sadomasochism on a civic level.

Eiffel strikes me as sort of a utilitarian skeleton piece; a proof of concept that made Lady Liberty a reality. But yeah, the tower itself is still kinda ugly, especially in comparison to the graceful and sinuous surroundings it was plopped into. I must admit that any true fan of Erector Sets would find it somewhat cool.

Notre-Dame, as a building, embodies Truth, Beauty, and Goodness, just as her faithful people do, and the edifice stands to project the Gospel of truth. I'd never object to a veggie garden, but perhaps let's not encourage gardeners to clomp around on the sacred roof.

John 20:15

Re:The Miraculous Resurrection of Notre-Dame by thrance on Sunday September 22, 2024 @05:03AM (#41615700)
That's a very wrong idea of beauty you have, there is no such thing as "objective quality".

Parisians hated it when Haussman rebuilt the city under Napoleon III, now it's considered one of the most picturesque cities in the world. Parisians hated it when the Eiffel Tower was built, now it's the symbol of France across the world and the most visited monument in the world. Parisians hated it when the pyramid of the Louvres was built, now new presidents do their inauguration speeches in front of it.

Point is, contemporary architecture is always ugly. Give it 50 years and it becomes historical and beloved.

Re:The Miraculous Resurrection of Notre-Dame by gjsman-1000 on Sunday September 22, 2024 @09:46AM (#41617046)
> contemporary architecture is always ugly. Give it 50 years and it becomes historical and beloved

Survivor’s fallacy. This doesn’t change that 98%+ of architecture has been ripped out and remodeled after 50 years. And some never catch on - almost everyone hates brutalism.

Re:The Miraculous Resurrection of Notre-Dame by AStonesThrow on Sunday September 22, 2024 @11:12AM (#41617610)
How very telling that you deny objectivity and then you go on to cite 4 examples where we should accept your objective, universal assertions, where you presume to speak for all of Paris, and every tourist and pilgrim to behold these beautiful sites!

I am pleased that you and the entire world uniformly consider Paris objectively beautiful, and I have no choice but to abandon my foolish, subjective judgements!

(Pro tip: symbols aren't expected to be beautiful or attractive, as long as they're accurate. Consider a long list of ugly and repulsive symbolism and synechode. Everyone knows that the Venus de Milo's arms were taken, and that's a reason for its fame.)

There is no shortage of people who are offended and repulsed by beautiful objects. Something or someone can be quite objectively beautiful, good and true, yet be considered unwanted or distasteful. Perhaps contemporary Parisians were more rankled by the excessive progress, destruction, and upheaval, than the architecture in itself? Greeks and others maintain ruins of formerly beautiful sites, in deplorable condition, yet people still visit the ugly pile of rocks?

Re:The Miraculous Resurrection of Notre-Dame by throw0101c on Sunday September 22, 2024 @03:27PM (#41619322)
> That's a very wrong idea of beauty you have, there is no such thing as "objective quality".

Not believing that there is such a thing as objective beauty is a recent phenomenon. Going back to ancient philosophers and in to the Italian Renaissance, the consensus was such a thing existed:

* https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/beauty/

And we don't have to go that far back to find it, as as 'recently' as the Victorian era architectural designs were based on such principals (such as the golden ratio):

* https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J-0XJpPnlrA

Having different be elements proportional to each other was basic stuff pre-WW2:

* https://www.youtube.com/@BrentHull/search?query=proportion

> Point is, contemporary architecture is always ugly. Give it 50 years and it becomes historical and beloved.

I'm not sure (m)any people find beauty in most of the brutalist buildings that are now ~50 years old.

Some of Le Corbusier's works are noted:

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Architectural_Work_of_Le_C...

but I'm not sure how many would be called "beloved".

Re:The Miraculous Resurrection of Notre-Dame by BrandoElFollito on Sunday September 22, 2024 @05:14AM (#41615751)
This was exactly the argument given over the centuries. These multiple "contemporary architectures" are what you admire today.
Re:The Miraculous Resurrection of Notre-Dame by seszett on Saturday September 21, 2024 @05:12PM (#41612706)
It's a bit different I think because the roof itself was never "preserved the best we can", it's "just" a sort of fantasy roof built at a time when Violet le Duc rebuilt many monuments using his imagination and fantasy with little historical basis.

I can't really say which would be best myself, but the point is since the roof is already the not historical part of the cathedral, it makes little sense to rebuild it exactly in that precise not historical way. Instead, it could keep being the one evolving part of the building.

Re:The Miraculous Resurrection of Notre-Dame by majormajor on Saturday September 21, 2024 @06:32PM (#41613139)
Historically the answer was "yes, rebuild the Colosseum with different materials," it's not just a modern thing. The desire to make it more original is stronger now than ever before in many places IMO.
Re:The Miraculous Resurrection of Notre-Dame by thrance on Saturday September 21, 2024 @05:21PM (#41612746)
Yeah, you have the right to your opinion too, and you're clearly in the majority so I respect that.

The last time Notre-Dame was rebuilt, by Viollet le Duc, it had been left in ruins for over a century and was redesigned as an idealized version of what it never was. So we are only preserving this version of the past by rebuilding it this way.

Also, a glass dome over the collosem would be hideous, which I think is reason enough not to do it :)

Re:The Miraculous Resurrection of Notre-Dame by BeFlatXIII on Sunday September 22, 2024 @01:12PM (#41618380)
Would the glass dome merely be a curiosity, or would it restore it to a functional building that's used for more than historic tourism?