Highcharts is very nice, but commercial (although there's a free license for non-commerical work available). I settled on flot eventually because it has a reasonably complete set of features, easy API, and there are lots of plugins available to complete all the features I wanted to have. A lot of the newer frameworks are less complete (for now, anway).
That said, I've admired D3 for a long time, it just didn't have a good basic time-series chart wrapper to help a JS newbie like me jump in. Rickshaw's a good start at that, but missing some features I need, like multiple Y-axes. A D3-based library is attractive, because I also want to integrate Cubism.js's horizon charts, and keeping them on the same rendering engine will cut down code size and be nicely consistent.
I did notice that browser performance at rendering SVG is still noticeably behind Canvas when you have lots of complex graphs on screen at once. The Rickshaw implementation of my dashboard (Rickshaw uses D3) slowed down considerably on my MacBook Air compaired to the flot version.
Cubism, D3, and now NVD3 are still very much in the running for v2 of my dashboard project.
I'm normally a server guy, but needed a good dashboard for our OpenTSDB metrics project, so I started diving into client-side JS -- going whole-hog on d3 without a good chart lib on top of it seemed to be a bit too steep of a learning curve. But I do love the possibility of open-ended charts, where we can dip into the power of d3 at will when we need something more custom.
Like DiabloD3 commented below, I feel like doing an end-zone victory dance :). Nice work.
(My particular sunny day wish list is for live & historical scientific strip chart style data logging: flexible date support, intuitive horizontal timeline dragging & zooming, live updating, line charts with gaps in them, rendering largish datasets (especially in a drill-down style), and logarithmic axes - especially if you can mix them with linear axes.)