What I think the parent is referring to is this: https://support.apple.com/en-us/120983
Obviously it is bullshit to suggest that a consumer would buy these tools. But it is also bullshit to suggest that you actually "need" a 'battery press' just because it is on the parts list.
The average phone repair shop will know how to loosen some battery adhesive very well with various techniques. So I don't think they will be discouraged by the Apple documentation.
Malicious compliance? Seems like it, a little bit. Still useful though.
I’m rich enough to buy the Apple tools but I’m too much of a grinch to buy them. I actually think iFixit protects me from myself as well because it’s too complicated (for me) to buy the tools I’d need.
If a customer does something stupid and breaks their phone then they shouldn't blame Apple, a responsible journalist won't make out that it's Apple's fault, a competent reader won't get the impression it was Apple's fault from an truthful article.
I know it's asking a lot for sensible action from consumers, responsible journalists, a discerning news audience, a megacorp that respects individual rights. I think ultimately this is Apple's problem and their customers and should hold them to a higher, pro-social standard. That could be through government regulation, wallet voting, or "unauthorized" repair.
"shouldn't blame", "responsible journalist", "competent reader".
I see you're an idealist. :)
Even ignoring the existence of plenty of less responsible “journalists”, if Apple were to publish “works reasonably well most of the time in the hands of a careful person with experience” repair manuals, I think it’s certain Apple would be blamed by almost all journalists.
And I don’t think adding stringent warnings to their manuals would make things better for them. On the contrary, I expect “the Internet” would burn them at the stake for adding those terms.
Any complaints shouldn’t be aimed against these repair methods, but at repairing being that difficult for modern stuff.
But even then, it’s hard to complain. Thing is: pouring lots of good glue inside a smartphone and making parts fit incredibly tight together makes them much stronger and makes it easier to make them water resistant.
For example, I bought the iFixit repair kit nearly a decade ago and I have used it for any minor work for all that time. $80 spent once and I’ve never once needed to fish for some strange bit or tool no matter what device I’ve opened. In fact, the iFixit kit will still be sufficient for this entire repair plus the 9 volt battery of course.
Unless you’re saying all these are one time use tools but I didn’t see that from the parts lists.