News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Starlink's new satellites emit 30x more radio interferenc... by ben_w on Friday September 20, 2024 @04:04AM (#41599832)
Astronomers don't have any control over the frequencies of light emitted by the stuff they're looking at, and they could previously rely on radio-quiet locations existing somehere on planet Earth.

> Same as we were fine with every other thing that seemed like it was going to destroy the world.

We might be, or not. Anthropic bias: we can only observe the dice rolls that don't kill us.

For all we know, attitudes like yours are the solution to the Fermi paradox.

But this isn't about "will destroy us", this is about "is this interference even necessary?" and "do your personal benefits outweigh the harms to others?"

If I were in charge of the would I would say "let's put the telescopes in space" — but as I'm not, that's promising jam tomorrow to someone who wants food today.

Re:Starlink's new satellites emit 30x more radio interferenc... by throwaway48540 on Friday September 20, 2024 @04:33AM (#41599974)
For all we know, the solution to Fermi paradox are people who insist on tradition and not upsetting the status quo instead of taking advantage of the possibilities of truly global high speed internet coverage for low prices.

I agree this should be fixed if it's possible. But if it meant 2x the price of the subscription, I'm pretty fine with them keeping it as it is. Global internet is just way too good for humanity to not do it.

Re:Starlink's new satellites emit 30x more radio interferenc... by ben_w on Friday September 20, 2024 @04:51AM (#41600062)
I'm not suggesting we don't want or benefit from high speed internet, I'm saying there's other ways of getting the same result, alternatives which don't mess with fundamental science for however long it takes to get around to building replacement radio telescopes in space.

And I'm saying this as someone who was seriously considering getting a Starlink connection (wired internet turned out to be good as well as cheap, but I was seriously considering Starlink).

> But if it meant 2x the price of the subscription, I'm pretty fine with them keeping it as it is.

If it was just about prices and nothing else, I'd be promoting the construction of an orbital ring launch system, which would inherently double as a global power grid and be a good place to mount PV.

Cheap space access (cheap enough to be used as a global 90-minute railway even if you have to go the long way around), cheap power supply (no clouds and less sun blocked by the air), cheap power transmission (because it's cross-subsidised with the other two).

> Global internet is just way too good for humanity to not do it.

So is "knowing where the asteroids are".