News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bankrupt Trucker Yellow Loses Ruling over $6.5B in Pensio... by jncfhnb on Wednesday September 18, 2024 @12:52PM (#41582321)
A pension plan is guaranteed. A 401k is not. A pension is theoretically much better because the company must pay you the money even if the investments didn’t work out. Contingent on the pension being there at the end of your career it’s much better. YMMV on getting a worse deal with a 401k that is more secure.

They can’t “take it away”. They just ran out of money with the judge ruling that shareholders don’t get priority access to what’s left.

Re:Bankrupt Trucker Yellow Loses Ruling over $6.5B in Pensio... by bb88 on Wednesday September 18, 2024 @01:02PM (#41582475)
Look at United Airlines.

UA didn't fund the pension plan, then declared bankruptcy in 2005 primarily to get the $10B pension off it's books.

Now that UA is profitable again, it's under no obligation to fund the pension plan it discharged from it's 2005 bankruptcy.

https://www.pbgc.gov/wr/large/united/united-airlines-plan-re...

Re:Bankrupt Trucker Yellow Loses Ruling over $6.5B in Pensio... by toomuchtodo on Wednesday September 18, 2024 @01:46PM (#41583119)
We're doing better. Just have to keep grinding.
Re:Bankrupt Trucker Yellow Loses Ruling over $6.5B in Pensio... by sokoloff on Wednesday September 18, 2024 @04:13PM (#41584898)
> A pension is theoretically much better because the company must pay you the money even if the investments didn’t work out.

A 401(k) is theoretically better because you can pass the unspent amount to your heirs.

(I make this post to point out that it’s a tradeoff, not that one is dominant over the other for all people/situations.)

Re:Bankrupt Trucker Yellow Loses Ruling over $6.5B in Pensio... by whartung on Wednesday September 18, 2024 @04:54PM (#41585351)
I think that depends. My Mother-in-Law continued to receive pension benefits from her late husband after he passed. I'm sure it depends on the pension and such.
Re:Bankrupt Trucker Yellow Loses Ruling over $6.5B in Pensio... by sokoloff on Thursday September 19, 2024 @07:17AM (#41590629)
Surviving spouse benefits are fairly common. That’s different from inheriting the unspent account balance in a 401(k).
Re:Bankrupt Trucker Yellow Loses Ruling over $6.5B in Pensio... by ghaff on Thursday September 19, 2024 @11:38AM (#41593018)
When I elected to start taking my pension I think there was an option to take a lower amount with a surviving spouse benefit. (Same is true for another annuity I have.) Different, as you say, from a pool of money that's "yours" with whatever tax consequences may be involved.
Re:Bankrupt Trucker Yellow Loses Ruling over $6.5B in Pensio... by blackeyeblitzar on Wednesday September 18, 2024 @02:15PM (#41583514)
Didn’t Boeing get rid of its pension plan? I don’t know the details but at least news interviews of striking union workers made it seem like a pension that they had worked for previously was then taken away, which seems unfair.
Re:Bankrupt Trucker Yellow Loses Ruling over $6.5B in Pensio... by jncfhnb on Wednesday September 18, 2024 @02:30PM (#41583705)
A quick Google suggests they stopped offering it and moved to a 401k, not that they just canceled their existing obligations.

This is generally the popular move because pensions plans create huge liabilities over time because you’re promising a final outcome rather than a promised level of funding.

Re:Bankrupt Trucker Yellow Loses Ruling over $6.5B in Pensio... by ghaff on Wednesday September 18, 2024 @03:08PM (#41584138)
Which is extremely common.

A ton of companies moved away from defined benefit plans. There's still on the hook (in general) for existing obligations; they can't just go "never mind" for the most part. They've just focused on different retirement benefits going forward.