But that's systemd the project, not systemd the init system. You don't need to use any of those components to use systemd, which has no dependencies on them. Those services can live and die on their own merits.
Re:A Word about Systemd
by bigfatkitten on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @09:09PM
(#41574653)
They can ship as much trash as they like, so long as it doesn't become my problem.
Those components become my problem when the distributions I choose to use choose to adopt them, and then I have to work around them.
Choose something else then. If there is one thing the world is not lacking it is Linux distros.
Re:A Word about Systemd
by bigfatkitten on Wednesday September 18, 2024 @07:55AM
(#41578592)
As a hobbyist, sure. It's not quite that simple when I have commercial apps I need to run in a regulated environment.
There's nothing about regulated environments or commercial apps that limit your choice to "systemd on Linux".
Everything is a tradeoff.
Re:A Word about Systemd
by bigfatkitten on Wednesday September 18, 2024 @05:11PM
(#41585553)
Those apps and the system's accreditation requirements limit my choice to a particular vendor's ecosystem so yes, they do.
Otherwise I could avoid Linux entirely if I so chose, and make the systemd consideration irrelevant.
Re:A Word about Systemd
by the_real_cher on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @09:33PM
(#41574809)
It becomes default on all the main stream distros though.
Which should make you consider its validity. If all these distros chose it, independent of one another, there's gotta be a reason. The reason is that it's much, much simpler and more maintainable from a distro perspective and a sysadmin perspective.
Ultimately distros decide what software is on their distro and users decide what distros to use. So the solution here is to find a distro that meets your needs.
systemd's developers have formed a habit of deciding to implement something like an NTP client or DNS resolver, bringing a healthy dose of ignorance of how those services actually work, and then doubling down on their poor design decisions when problems are brought to their attention.