News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Why there is only one network? by solardev on Monday September 16, 2024 @10:08AM (#41556232)
You can start a service like that and put it on the existing internet if you want. You can bypass DNS and make your own routing if you want. Onion and Freenet and blockchains and DHTs and content addressable systems work similarly. But nobody uses them because they're such a hassle.

Again, what you're describing is more an application or protocol, not a network necessarily. You can build it all in software on top of the existing internet.

Re:Ask HN: Why there is only one network? by nwhnwh on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @11:18PM (#41575426)
Can you recommend a book that could explain these topics especially the protocols in a good way? I hated network classes in college.
Re:Ask HN: Why there is only one network? by solardev on Wednesday September 18, 2024 @11:40AM (#41581198)
Sorry, networking isn't my specialization, and I never read a book on those topics. (I know vaguely what they are and a little about how they work, but not enough to reimplement any of them on my own.) But many of those projects are open-source, so you can see the discussions (and code) about how they were built.

IMHO: I think maybe you're overthinking this a bit though...? If your end goal is just to have a place where people discuss primarily (or exclusively) over text, then all you really need is a web app that enforces that, like HN does. You can probably find some HN clone or reddit clone software and just use that, or Discourse (the forum, not Discord the chat app), and remove any multimedia functionality they might have. Or host your own IRC or Usenet server and don't allow images.

I don't think this is really a technical issue to solve, but a cultural one. Such places aren't common/popular because "I never want to see an image" isn't a big priority to most people. It'll be hard to get traction on such a forum, no matter how you build it under the hood.