News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:OpenAI threatens to revoke o1 access for asking it about ... by islewis on Friday September 13, 2024 @05:08PM (#41535146)
The words "internal thought process" seem to flag my questions. Just asking for an explanation of thoughts doesn't.

If I ask for an explanation of "internal feelings" next to a math questions, I get this interesting snippet back inside of the "Thought for n seconds" block:

> Identifying and solving

> I’m mapping out the real roots of the quadratic polynomial 6x^2 + 5x + 1, ensuring it’s factorized into irreducible elements, while carefully navigating OpenAI's policy against revealing internal thought processes.

Re:OpenAI threatens to revoke o1 access for asking it about ... by csours on Friday September 13, 2024 @05:33PM (#41535379)
> "internal feelings"

I've often thought of using the words "internal reactions" as a euphemism for emotions.

Re:OpenAI threatens to revoke o1 access for asking it about ... by chankstein38 on Friday September 13, 2024 @05:14PM (#41535200)
They figured out how to make it completely useless I guess. I was disappointed but not surprised when they said they weren't going to show us chain of thought. I assumed we'd still be able to ask clarifying questions but apparently they forgot that's how people learn. Or they know and they would rather we just turn to them for our every thought instead of learning on our own.
Re:OpenAI threatens to revoke o1 access for asking it about ... by makomk on Friday September 13, 2024 @05:38PM (#41535426)
Yeah, that is a worry: maybe OpenAI's business model and valuation rest on reasoning abilities becoming outdated and atrophying outside of their algorithmic black box, a trade secret we don't have access too. It struck me as an obvious possible concern when the o1 announcement released, but too speculative and conspiratorial to point out - but how hard they're apparently trying to stop it from explaining its reasoning in ways that humans can understand is alarming.
Re:OpenAI threatens to revoke o1 access for asking it about ... by mannanj on Friday September 13, 2024 @06:36PM (#41535842)
You have to remember they appointed a CIA director on their board. Not exactly the organization known for wanting a freely thinking citizenry, as their agenda and operation mockingbird allows for legal propaganda on us. This would be the ultimate tool for that.