News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"Stockholm Syndrome" was invented by police to discredit ... by andrewla on Friday September 13, 2024 @11:17AM (#41532015)
"Told them point blank" -- I mean, there was no private channel where police could confidentially tell the hostages about this. It's a negotiation point -- make the hostage-takers aware that they do not have unlimited immunity from consequences just because they have hostages. If the police had caused injury to come to a hostage, whether as collateral damage from police action or from the captors retaliating for police action, the afterwards I can see this being a cause of concern for the hostages.

"Pop science" seems orthogonal to this concept -- it's like saying the concept of "jury of your peers" is pop science. It's a phenomenon that has some descriptive power, that's all. I mean, if you're going to say that in a hostage situation, it's okay for the police to deliberately endanger or harm the hostages because of Stockholm Syndrome, then that's clearly a misuse. But in hostage negotation and rescue, keeping in mind that the hostages may not be sympathetic or cooperative with the authorities seems like a really great thing to keep in mind.

Re:"Stockholm Syndrome" was invented by police to discredit ... by jjk166 on Friday September 13, 2024 @12:32PM (#41532762)
> Sensing that their likelihood of survival was getting slimmer by the hour, Enmark took matters into her own hands. She called the Swedish prime minister, Olof Palme, and begged him to let her and another hostage leave the bank with their captors. ‘I fully trust Clark and the robber,’ she told Palme. ‘I am not desperate. They haven’t done athing to us. On the contrary, they have been very nice. But you know, Olof, what I’m scared of is that the police will attack and cause us to die.’ Palme refused to let her leave, saying they could not give in to the demands of criminals. At the end of the conversation, Enmark says Palme said ‘Well, Kristin, you can’t get out of the bank. You will have to content yourself that you will have died at your post.’

If someone said this to you, would you be on their side?

> "Pop science" seems orthogonal to this concept -- it's like saying the concept of "jury of your peers" is pop science.

What? Pop science in this context means something that is widely believed to be rooted in scientific fact by the general public but actually isn't.

> But in hostage negotiation and rescue, keeping in mind that the hostages may not be sympathetic or cooperative with the authorities seems like a really great thing to keep in mind.

That's moving the goal posts dramatically. The whole point of this article is that stockholm syndrome does not have descriptive power because there are no scientific criteria to delineate what it is, when it's happening, or even if it's real. You can name things that don't exist, like dragons, but that does not mean people should be using dragons as an explanation for what they observe.

Re:"Stockholm Syndrome" was invented by police to discredit ... by mewpmewp2 on Friday September 13, 2024 @01:04PM (#41533056)
But how can a rational person believe the police is at fault compared to captors like it's a normal thing to take hostages?
Re:"Stockholm Syndrome" was invented by police to discredit ... by GeoAtreides on Friday September 13, 2024 @01:34PM (#41533333)
Surely the question is whose fault it is, but whose side offers more chances for survival; apparently, in this case, it was the wrong side.
Re:"Stockholm Syndrome" was invented by police to discredit ... by lbwtaylor on Friday September 13, 2024 @02:45PM (#41533943)
You can desire the police cooperate with the hostage takers, without taking the side of the hostage takers.

The proof is in the pudding - the police ended the hostage taking with no lives lost. To after the fact continue to take the side of the hostage takers is pretty terrible to me. All of this is Olsson's fault.

Re:"Stockholm Syndrome" was invented by police to discredit ... by octopoc on Friday September 13, 2024 @03:01PM (#41534089)
What constitutes "taking the hostage takers' side"? She's not begging that the police release the perps, she's not saying that they were within their rights to rob the bank or anything like that. It's more complicated than just "she is taking the police's side" vs "she is taking the perps' side".
Re:"Stockholm Syndrome" was invented by police to discredit ... by mewpmewp2 on Friday September 13, 2024 @05:21PM (#41535263)
But the fact that she's talking fondly of the hostage takers is exactly the evidence of phenomena of the stockholm syndrome.

Could police have done things better? For sure. Were they inexperienced with the hostage situation? Yeah.

But to speak negatively of the people trying to diffuse the situation and positively of the hostage takers is what is definition of the stockholm syndrome, because clearly none of it would've happened if it wasn't for the hostage takers.

The fact that she's not actively condemning the criminals and hostage takers speaks volumes to me.

Re:"Stockholm Syndrome" was invented by police to discredit ... by gqcwwjtg on Friday September 13, 2024 @10:56PM (#41537145)
Maybe chill out on criticizing the reaction of someone involved in such a traumatic scenario where they’re not treated well by any side. It’s not what the article is about and it’s pretty gross.
Re:"Stockholm Syndrome" was invented by police to discredit ... by engineer_22 on Friday September 13, 2024 @01:46PM (#41533430)
Humans aren't rational, they're made of flesh and blood.
Re:"Stockholm Syndrome" was invented by police to discredit ... by mewpmewp2 on Friday September 13, 2024 @05:23PM (#41535291)
And for those irrational cases we have labels and descriptions such as stockholm syndrome, or social anxiety disorder and whatnot.
Re:"Stockholm Syndrome" was invented by police to discredit ... by RevEng on Saturday September 14, 2024 @12:39PM (#41540885)
Irrational behavior goes well beyond clinical mental disorders. There are dozens of known biases and heuristics that we all follow every day that are irrational. There's a big difference between disproportionately attributing blame and a mental disorder like Stockholm syndrome. Just look at any news post here and watch people make wild accusations against all parties involved based on a 500 word synopsis of an otherwise complicated incident that is still under investigation. It happens constantly.
Re:"Stockholm Syndrome" was invented by police to discredit ... by potato3983 on Friday September 13, 2024 @02:33PM (#41533829)
In the moment it's not a question of fault or good vs bad. It's a question of who do you cast your lot in with in order to have a better chance of exiting the situation alive. Stuff like helping law enforcement or getting back at the bad guys only matters so long as it isn't likely to get you dead.

You're valuable to the hostage takers so long as you're alive. Your continued existence is a nuisance to the police. But obviously the police with their infinite money and manpower have better odds on their side. Situation specific facts must be taken into consideration, etc, etc.

Re:"Stockholm Syndrome" was invented by police to discredit ... by mewpmewp2 on Friday September 13, 2024 @05:25PM (#41535303)
These are all good explanations for the phenomena, and if you are being taken hostage, it is even rational to empathize with whoever took you hostage to maximize chances of your survival. I think the syndrome part is when you are out of that situation, but still continue to be kind to the hostage takers, and/or keep yourself intentionally in the dangerous situation to be with the hostage taker.
Re:"Stockholm Syndrome" was invented by police to discredit ... by jjk166 on Friday September 13, 2024 @06:01PM (#41535600)
How can a rational person not? The police had the opportunity to deescalate, which would increase their chances of survival, and they chose not to. It would be like if a mugger stabbed you, and the ER surgeon refused to operate on you to save you - you can and should fault both.

If I were ever in that situation, I would 100% fault the police for their behavior, and I would question the sanity of anyone who didn't.

Re:"Stockholm Syndrome" was invented by police to discredit ... by andrewla on Friday September 13, 2024 @12:46PM (#41532899)
If Clark had a gun to my head and Olof was refusing to give them what they wanted I would be pretty upset with Olof but way more upset with Clark. I might convince myself that Clark is super nice and only holding a gun to my head because of something something, but that's the essence of Stockholm syndrome in the end.

I disagree that Stockholm syndrome is "widely believed to be rooted in scientific fact" -- I would say that "Stockholm Syndrome is widely believed to be a real phenomenon" and remove the pretension of "science" from the equation entirely.

I don't feel that I'm moving the goalposts -- what, in your mind, is the "application" of the theory of Stockholm Syndrome other than what I've said here? Do you honestly believe that hostage negotiators are saying "if the hostages get in your way, shoot them because they have Stockholm Syndrome Which Is A Scientific Fact"?