Re:Craigslist, LinkedIn, Netflix, and others don't owe us an...
by sirclueless on Saturday June 23, 2012 @10:37PM
(#4152429)
Agreed. My argument was perhaps a little strong. Craigslist is far from a monopoly and people can and do successfully list their apartments in all sorts of places.
I do think there are web companies who could really do some anti-competitive things that we should watch out for. Facebook is probably the most capable, or maybe Google if they went off the deep end and started holding companies hostage through their search. The argument still stands, I think, even if it doesn't justify intervening on behalf of a company that wants to improve Craigslist search.
What most on HN don't want to admit is that the brilliance of their code or the beauty of their design alone are not enough to guarantee success. We still have to market our wares and if the value derived from our code+designs isn't greater than the value provided by CL's network + usability + cost then that doesn't mean we call our parents or a referee or a senator and tell them we need the playing field leveled because the end users are too lazy to see how deserving we are of their business.
Paper classified still exist, web based CL alternatives still exist (Backpages.com is a big one), CL is not a monopoly and a "superauthority" is not the answer.
And how would we know when a "superauthority" needs to step in, "judiciously applied" is subjective. Successful passing of SOPA would have been "judiciously applied" "superauthority" in the eyes of the entertainment industry.
I'm of the belief that the free market isn't perfect, maybe not even close to it, but I don't think you've explained how the free market has failed to address the HN community's "perceived" problem that CL presents.