I don't have much experience with Haskell, but one of the worst experiences has been Stack's compile time dependency on GitHub. GitHub rate limits you and builds take forever.
- Binary upgrade of Stack fails due to GitHub API request limit #4979 (https://github.com/commercialhaskell/stack/issues/4979)
- GitHub rate limiting can affect Stack CI #6034 (https://github.com/commercialhaskell/stack/issues/6034)
And a few more. The "fix" is having Stack impersonate the user (https://github.com/commercialhaskell/stack/pull/6036) and authenticate to the API. This unblocks progress, but this is really a design bug and not something I think people should emulate.
Every other language I've used allows you to build code without authenticating to a remote service.
> Every other language I've used allows you to build code without authenticating to a remote service.
Sure, the problem here wasn't "building". It was downloading a package template (which one doesn't tend to do 60 times per hour). I agree packages shouldn't be fetched from GitHub.
That comment is from someone other than the ticket filer who was seeing another issue even after sending the GitHub token. It was this second issue that wasn't caused by GitHub rate limiting -- the original one was.
> It was downloading a package template (which one doesn't tend to do 60 times per hour).
I've personally had Stack-related GitHub API rate limiting delay builds by at least an hour due to extreme slowness. So whatever the rate limits are, Stack occasionally hits them.
That's why I've been writing an HTTP server in Idris2 instead. Here's a todo list demo app[1] and a hello world demo[2]. The advantage of Idris is that it compiles to e.g. Racket, a high level language with a concurrent runtime you can bind to from Idris.
It's also interesting how languages don't need their own hosting (e.g. Hackage) any more. Idris packages are just listed in a TOML file[3] (like Stackage) but still hosted on GitHub. No need for versions, just use git commit hashes. It's all experimental anyway.
[1]: https://janus.srht.site/docs/todolist.html [2]: https://git.sr.ht/~janus/web-server-racket-hello-world/tree/... [3]: https://github.com/stefan-hoeck/idris2-pack-db/blob/main/STA...