Re:Neither Elon Musk nor Anybody Else Will Ever Colonize Mars
by arder on Thursday September 12, 2024 @03:52AM
(#41518509)
You know this guy gets paid by the word because he spends about a thousand words saying "The earth is more hospitable than Mars and there's still places on earth where life basically doesn't survive". Which is one argument, made in an extremely long way. But the counter is surely "Yes, everything that could live at the top of mount everest prefers to live at the foot of mount everest, that option is not available to life on mars". Or "Everest is uninhabitable because we've never tried to make it habitable".
I was hoping there would be a hard scientific fact the author would state like "It doesn't have a magnetic field and solar flares do X" but we didn't quite get there.
A lot of doomsterism in this article is incredibly one sided. Yes, it's true the sun will be around for another 4 billion years, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't go to mars, it means you get to ask the quesiton "Do you think at some point over the course of the next 4 billion years we'll successfully create a martian colony?". 4 billion years! We're talking about 4 billion years and you're worried about the carbon foot print of coffee beans?
I fundamentally agree that Musk's particular effort is pie in the sky. But (a) the steps along the way aren't (starlink, cheap satellites) and (b) it's his money he can fuck all the way off with it - I'd rather he spent the money shooting for Mars than shooting to land little orange men into the white house.
Re:Neither Elon Musk nor Anybody Else Will Ever Colonize Mars
by Zigurd on Thursday September 12, 2024 @12:07PM
(#41522406)
Any dope can dream of such things, but Elon has put his dreams to practical use: building a cult of personality with which he creates meme stock valuations among other cult leader shenanigans.
Re:Neither Elon Musk nor Anybody Else Will Ever Colonize Mars
by big-green-man on Thursday September 12, 2024 @04:06PM
(#41524949)
This article is absurd.
"No life lives at the south pole or everest, which are orders of magnitude squared more hospitable than any place on mars, why has life not done it by itself?" OK, we aren't talking about seeding mars with archaea and letting nature take it's course.
The author conflates terraforming with colonization. Mars will never be terraformed. At least not in such a way as to allow humans to go outside naked. Martians will be mole people.
"Humans can't be bothered to colonize mount everest and the south pole which are right there, but they're going to go 44 million miles and do it in an even harder place?" Yes, that's the plan. You know why we don't colonize mount everest? Because there's no payoff, a quick boat ride or plane flight away there are numerous places where no work must be done to live comfortably. There's no reason to do it.
Compare that to Mars, where it's the closest outpost to our destiny. We live on an island. We are trapped. We can't grow indefinitely here. There are experiences impossible here even with the seemingly endless arrangements of life and human culture, and minds driven to experience them, whatever they may be. Mars isn't some remote desert island in a vast sea of nothing, it's the closest point in a vast frontier that our people need to populate, or else.
"If evolution didn't colonize mount everest and the south pole, we don't stand a chance on mars." This to me is the biggest stretch in the article. We do all sorts of things evolution didn't do for billions of years. We will try novel things and we will make it happen. Just like we always do.
Can Elon do it? I don't know. I do know that he's the person on the earth right now who stands the best chance, I don't think there's anyone else on earth who could pull it off this generation. It's still a long shot to put it lightly, but for him I think it is doable. But if it's not him, down the road I think it is going to happen.
I was hoping there would be a hard scientific fact the author would state like "It doesn't have a magnetic field and solar flares do X" but we didn't quite get there.
A lot of doomsterism in this article is incredibly one sided. Yes, it's true the sun will be around for another 4 billion years, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't go to mars, it means you get to ask the quesiton "Do you think at some point over the course of the next 4 billion years we'll successfully create a martian colony?". 4 billion years! We're talking about 4 billion years and you're worried about the carbon foot print of coffee beans?
I fundamentally agree that Musk's particular effort is pie in the sky. But (a) the steps along the way aren't (starlink, cheap satellites) and (b) it's his money he can fuck all the way off with it - I'd rather he spent the money shooting for Mars than shooting to land little orange men into the white house.
"No life lives at the south pole or everest, which are orders of magnitude squared more hospitable than any place on mars, why has life not done it by itself?" OK, we aren't talking about seeding mars with archaea and letting nature take it's course.
The author conflates terraforming with colonization. Mars will never be terraformed. At least not in such a way as to allow humans to go outside naked. Martians will be mole people.
"Humans can't be bothered to colonize mount everest and the south pole which are right there, but they're going to go 44 million miles and do it in an even harder place?" Yes, that's the plan. You know why we don't colonize mount everest? Because there's no payoff, a quick boat ride or plane flight away there are numerous places where no work must be done to live comfortably. There's no reason to do it.
Compare that to Mars, where it's the closest outpost to our destiny. We live on an island. We are trapped. We can't grow indefinitely here. There are experiences impossible here even with the seemingly endless arrangements of life and human culture, and minds driven to experience them, whatever they may be. Mars isn't some remote desert island in a vast sea of nothing, it's the closest point in a vast frontier that our people need to populate, or else.
"If evolution didn't colonize mount everest and the south pole, we don't stand a chance on mars." This to me is the biggest stretch in the article. We do all sorts of things evolution didn't do for billions of years. We will try novel things and we will make it happen. Just like we always do.
Can Elon do it? I don't know. I do know that he's the person on the earth right now who stands the best chance, I don't think there's anyone else on earth who could pull it off this generation. It's still a long shot to put it lightly, but for him I think it is doable. But if it's not him, down the road I think it is going to happen.