As I wrote in another thread, that's not how business works in the EU. If Volkswagen, incorporated in Germany, sells a car in Poland, they're not required to pay a corresponding sliver of their net profits to the Polish exchequer. It all stays in Germany.
The second it advantages another EU country at their expense, however...
I believe that part of the reason is that they still pay other taxes (eg VAT) in the country of sale.
If there was a 20% tax on revenue, companies would increase prices in kind…
Do the dollars that make up the profits, and the dollars that make up the taxes on profits, come from somewhere else than the dollars that make up the VAT?
The evidence that this is correct follows: visitors, tourists if you prefer, can collect reimbursement for VAT payments, the first link I hit was Norway but this is very common if not universal: https://www.toll.no/en/tourist-in-norway/reimbursement-of-va...
If VAT were a tax on the corporation, it would make no sense at all to reimburse it to specific consumers who are not obliged to pay it. That only makes sense when the tax is on the consumer, and merely collected by the corporation. Which is how VAT works.
The VAT sum is recorded at the time of sale, but the whole amount sits in the company finances until the VAT is settled with the exchequer.
The company holds the VAT sum between collection and settlement, potentially benefiting from the temporary cash flow in that period.
If they weren’t taxes intended to fall only on the consumer then:
* businesses wouldn’t be able to claim back sales taxes on their purchases.
* consumers wouldn’t be personally liable for taxes on goods they import.
This is hard to implement in practice.
Imagine selling in a country with 50% tax, and having a country with 10% somehwere, anywhere in the world.
For easier math, let's say you buy dildos from a chinese manufacture for 1eur (including shipping), and sell them for 11eur to end customers. You've just earned 10eur, and you're taxed 5eur, giving you 5eur of profit.
What you then do is open a company in a low-tax country, the company is "completely independent" and the owner (your cousin) works with both the manufacturer and you. You buy the dildos from your cousin for 10eur, he buys them from china for 1eur has them shipped directly to you, and you sell them for 11eur.
So, your cousin earned 9eur, and will pay 10% tax on that (90c, 8.10eur of profit) and you earned 1eur, and will pay 50% tax on that (50c, 50c of profit for you).
So instead of paying 5eur in tax, you only paid 1.40eur, and pocketed 8.6eur. Yes, there are some additional costs (another company + paperwork, some percentage for your cousin) but you still earned more.
The same can be done with patents and licences, branding deals, etc. Company in rich country made 100M of profits... just have the company in a cheap-tax country charge them 99M for licencing, 1M gets taxed in the expensive-tax country, and 99M in the cheap one.
A great number of tricks go away if you treat subsidiaries as a single company. Countries are reluctant to pierce the corporate veil, but it’s all arbitrary rules.
And for every regulatory change will bring changes to tax avoidance... subsidiaries will just get "one more step" removed from the main company...
The idea that subsidiaries, trusts, etc have any meaning whatsoever when collecting taxes is simply a loophole which can be closed at any time.
The irony as I see it, was that the software was developed by us locally and used by local clients, but somehow ended up being "owned" by carribean islands.
Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix (2007) ended up with a $167 million loss on paper after grossing nearly $1 billion. According to New Line's accounts, the LOTR trilogy made "horrendous losses" and no profit at all. Same as Forrest Gump, Men in Black, and Return of the Jedi.
The Music industry is far worse in its financial machinations.
With some minor exceptions, the companies involved in this are all American.
I think it should be 0 and we should tax use of resources and consumption instead. Then let countries compete to create business friendly environment. It doesn't provide enough revenue to be worth all the hassle with enforcement and accounting.
This is will force a political crisis as the government is complaining it has no money to build houses. So all the those comments saying other EU countries just has to sue Ireland to get some of that won't happen.
If Germany gave state aid to Deusche Bank and DB operates in many EU countries it wouldn't make any sense for Spain to get a cut of that if they were forced to hand it back, even if the revenue was generated in other countries by DB this doesn't concern the state aid given.
no it won't
> as the government is complaining it has no money to build houses
no it isn't
The government isn't really blaming lack of money on the housing crisis more they are claiming it takes time.
The government couldn't even spend an allocated €1 billion of its housing budget over the last three years. https://www.thejournal.ie/housing-budget-underspend-6038256-...
If you were Irish you'd know exactly the issue - a mix between the local planning and rural needs schemes which prevent one-off building in established rural communities, and the farce that is An Bord Pleanála - our Planning Authority.
Given our absolute position as a Republic and a Democracy, we have incredible powers for individuals to block major developments. The one in the major Dublin suburb of Dundrum, adjacent the largest shopping Centre in Europe, is just the tip of the iceberg.
https://www.independent.ie/podcasts/the-indo-daily/indo-dail...
Does this also have the knock on affect that these companies can now write off this tax so their owed US taxes are much less (assuming they ever repatriate these earning - which they have often avoided to avoid paying US tax)?
Anyways, writing the above shows me how much I don't understand about these cases.