Re:Selling a used iPod can violate a copyright law
by btilly on Friday June 22, 2012 @09:16PM
(#4149729)
I have not been following the case. But normal practice is that when you sue someone, you put forth every legal argument that you can think of in the hope that at least one sticks. And any lines of reasoning that come with minimum damages are even better, because you want to sue for as much as you can. (I believe that copyright infringement comes with fairly significant minimum penalties.)
This often leads to weird counter-factual arguments of the form, "A is true, and if A is true, then my client should win. Even if A proves false, B is true, and if B is true then my client should win. Even if B is also false..." If you think A you can show that A is true, why do you need the rest? Because this is about convincing the judge, not about the rest. No matter how clearly A is true, there is a chance the judge will disagree with you, and you still want to leave them a way to rule in your favor.
This often leads to weird counter-factual arguments of the form, "A is true, and if A is true, then my client should win. Even if A proves false, B is true, and if B is true then my client should win. Even if B is also false..." If you think A you can show that A is true, why do you need the rest? Because this is about convincing the judge, not about the rest. No matter how clearly A is true, there is a chance the judge will disagree with you, and you still want to leave them a way to rule in your favor.
Not, IANAL, this is likewise not legal advice.