News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google to launch Amazon, Microsoft cloud competitor at Go... by digeridoo on Friday June 22, 2012 @06:58PM (#4149315)
Amazon did not get lucky with their products. They developed them over a number of years, constantly adapting to customer demands and trying various different types of services. Being able to do this is a luxury that start-ups cannot afford, they need to get lucky with their choices, but Google could have done it.

I wasn't making a GAE vs. AWS comparison though. GAE is not in direct competition with AWS. It's a product with a niche market and I wouldn't see it as a failure. It's just something else entirely than building an AWS competitor.

The argument I was making is that Google wouldn't necessarily have the experience in building a lean, scalable business operation that could successfully compete with Amazon Web Services. As a case in point, Google has been running an exact duplicate of Amazon S3 for a while now, but it has yet to really take off. http://cloud.google.com/products/cloud-storage.html

Re:Google to launch Amazon, Microsoft cloud competitor at Go... by ajross on Friday June 22, 2012 @07:03PM (#4149339)
> Amazon did not get lucky with their products. They developed them over a number of years,

EC2 and S3 today are virtually identical to the services they launched with. I don't think reality bears out your contention.

You're right that they had to add EBS later, but I think if anything that supports my point: the ephemeral "instance store" model was too weird, and customers really wanted something that acted like a virtual hard drive with persistent storage.