Re:Selling a used iPod can violate a copyright law
by excuse-me on Friday June 22, 2012 @06:56PM
(#4149305)
On the other hand, suppose a group of car makers all coincidentally decided to impose this - purely for safety concerns.
And while they couldn't ban after market parts, they could make the engine not start if the new brakes/mufflers/cat didn't give the correct crypto response to the engine management system.
And just imagine that congress would bow down to the car makers (that it had just bailed out) and rule that you couldn't modify the engine computer - in the interests of safety of course.
Re:Selling a used iPod can violate a copyright law
by rdl on Saturday June 23, 2012 @05:51AM
(#4150484)
I think the Nissan GT-R had some components like this, actually.
Re:Selling a used iPod can violate a copyright law
by tikhonj on Saturday June 23, 2012 @06:25AM
(#4150533)
Did it? All I heard was that it had certain components hand-built and customized to each other (like the engine and the transmission). However, this is an entirely mechanical issue: since it wasn't really mass-produced, each motor and gearbox is different, so replacing them is going to be nontrivial.
Of course, I'm not an expert, and could certainly be missing information on other components of the GT-R. Either way, it's useful to keep in mind that the GT-R is a really crazy car :P.
Of course, this only works for really expensive but limited edition cars. If there is a several year waiting list just to get the chance to drop half a million on a car, the car maker can get away with almost anything--the customer is obviously willing to go through a lot of trouble! This is designed to stop people from flipping supercars.
Also, there is a very important difference between a voluntary contract and an abuse of copyright law. Now, if every car maker mandated such a contract on every car, it would be a big issue even if it was ostensibly voluntary. In a free market, some other company not mandating such a contract would emerge; however, markets rarely function perfectly. I think this is an interesting parallel to the whole safe boot nonsense: if there was more diversity in the market it wouldn't be an issue, but the market is heavily dominated by a handful of companies, so it is an issue from a purely practical standpoint.