News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by pelle on Tuesday December 30, 2008 @06:15PM (#414824)
Health care is no different than any other service. If you are able to increase the availability as well as lower the price it helps everyone. Including the poor.
Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by davidw on Tuesday December 30, 2008 @06:27PM (#414838)
There's always going to be a cutoff point, though, where people are unprofitable. Introducing some market oriented reforms might improve things, but you simply can't get around the fact that in a purely profit-oriented system, some people are not worth the money it would cost to save their lives or reduce their suffering.

There are plenty of products where the market drives prices down, but doesn't make them free or available to everyone, and in most cases that's just fine. Some people and some societies take the view that in some way or another, things like food, shelter, and yes, at least basic health care ought to be available to everyone, even if it is not profitable. That's "social engineering".

Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by mmmurf on Tuesday December 30, 2008 @08:41PM (#414954)
True. I don't think anyone would object to helping the 1% of people who are actually in that category. The problem is that interest groups hijack the programs in order to win handouts for those who don't really need the programs.
Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by loumf on Tuesday December 30, 2008 @10:39PM (#415071)
Where does this 1% come from? As a back of the envelope calculation, I would guess that almost all senior citizens are unprofitable to insure -- that's way more than 1%. Even if I'm off by a lot, it's still way more than 1% -- and I haven't addressed the rest of the population.
Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by mmmurf on Wednesday December 31, 2008 @11:58AM (#415634)
Only unprofitable if you decide that everyone deserves the latest, greatest, cutting-edge medical care.

Healthcare prices have come way down in the past two decades, the issue is that nobody wants 1990 level care, which could be administered at a fraction of the price of delivering all of the latest advancements.

The "healthcare costs are rising" meme is false. It's like saying "the price of supercomputers is rising". In non-inflation-adjusted dollars, the top-end supercomputer from IBM costs more than the top-end supercomputer from IBM cost 10 years ago, but the price per unit of computation has gone way down.

Healthcare prices have done the same thing, but everyone wants the best possible at all times.

(I want this too, but at least I try to appreciate that what I'm getting today is significantly better than 10 years ago)

Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by arockwell on Wednesday December 31, 2008 @04:36AM (#415333)
Take a look at a list of what is considered an uninsurable condition for personal health insurance. That alone would hit more than 1% of the population.
Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by mmmurf on Wednesday December 31, 2008 @11:59AM (#415638)
Do you happen to have a list of these?
Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by arockwell on Thursday January 01, 2009 @03:34PM (#416650)
I think it is state by state, but quite possibly varies from company to company. I found this list (which is similar to ones I've seen before), which is for Ohio: http://www.healthcarereform.ohio.gov/HCRDoc/RepresentativeLi.... Some of the ones on the list are pretty shocking and many of them are hereditary.
Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by gnaritas on Tuesday December 30, 2008 @06:29PM (#414842)
Health is very different from other services, profit should not be the goal. Business does not attempt to help people, but to maximize profit, which does not necessarily mean increasing availability or lowering prices at all. It might be more profitable to dump the lower income people and jack up the prices on those who can afford it.

Unlike other industries, getting service is often a literal life or death issue, you have to pay or you might die; morally this makes health care very different from other industries.

Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by benl on Tuesday December 30, 2008 @07:40PM (#414909)
Profit is the world's way of signaling that you are doing something in an efficient, effective, and long-term sustainable way.

So, given that health care is one of the most fundamental individual needs, profit most definitely should be the goal.

But health care is not the most fundamental need -- that would be food. I find it puzzling that people don't apply the same arguement to this need. Why not say that profit shouldn't be the goal of the food industry? And that supermarkets are immoral for making a profit at the expense of hungry people? Well, because it's clearly nonsense, of course.

But I wonder if it would seem like nonsense if we lived in a world where there was no free market in food supply. We might worry that greedy corporations would only be interested in serving expensive foods to rich people.

Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by calambrac on Tuesday December 30, 2008 @09:30PM (#415001)
You have to be kidding. Regarding food production, go read the Omnivore's Dilemma, go read up on issues with food patents, go read up on the costs of raising meat (which, in effect, only the wealthy can afford to eat). You are in a deep, delusional fantasy if you think the world's food industry is a paragon of efficiency, effectiveness, and long-term sustainability.
Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by benl on Tuesday December 30, 2008 @09:44PM (#415012)
"the costs of raising meat (which, in effect, only the wealthy can afford to eat)"

I guess the 99 cent hamburger must also be part of my delusion, then.

Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by calambrac on Tuesday December 30, 2008 @09:53PM (#415027)
Yes, it is, actually. It's amazing that you would cite McDonald's while arguing against a form of government subsidies. Seriously, go read the Omnivore's Dilemma.
Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by gnaritas on Tuesday December 30, 2008 @09:08PM (#414974)
The problem with that viewpoint is it assumes people are inherently good; they aren't. When profit is the goal, people suffer. I find the idea that seeking profit automatically creates the best good rather naive and idealistic.

Of course people don't apply the same argument to food, food isn't scarce for most of us and few have problems acquiring it and the ability to produce it can't be easily collected in the hands of a few, anyone can grow their own food.

Anyone cannot operate on themselves and perform some life saving operation, and while those who can certainly deserve to be compensated greatly for that ability they walk a fine moral line knowing their product, or the refusal to provide it, will directly kill people. Doctors are much more like firemen and policeman that businessman. Society has certain expectations of them serving the greater good of the community and helping people when they're in need.

The free market is not the cure for every ill and seeking profit is not, and should not be the goal of every job. Greed is not some inherently good moral trait.

Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by benl on Tuesday December 30, 2008 @09:41PM (#415010)
You've got it backwards -- the very reason that food is plentiful is that there is profit to be made in growing and selling it.

Your statement:

"food isn't scarce for most of us and few have problems acquiring it and the ability to produce it can't be easily collected in the hands of a few, anyone can grow their own food"

is directly contradicted by the millions who starved to death when food production was collectivised under various profit-hating communist regimes.

Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by gnaritas on Tuesday December 30, 2008 @09:46PM (#415016)
A statement I'm making about us in the present, is not contradicted because at sometime in the past in some other country under totally different conditions it wasn't true.

That may serve as a counter example, but it doesn't contradict what I said. America is not Russia and just because it went down that way for them does not mean that's how it'll play out for us. Knowing some history is one thing, trying to predict the future from it is another.

You seem to be hung up on extremes, that's not the real world. If I say the free market isn't the solution to every problem it doesn't imply I think it's the solution to no problem and suddenly I'm a communist.

Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by benl on Tuesday December 30, 2008 @10:22PM (#415053)
Don't worry -- I didn't call you a communist. I can cite counter-examples without name-calling.
Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by michaelkeenan on Wednesday December 31, 2008 @02:09AM (#415242)
I have sympathy for your point of view. But I worry that attempting to remove the profit motive from healthcare could result in potential doctors choosing different professions.

A problem with society having "certain expectations" of doctors - or anyone else - is that extra expectations (above "do a job so that trading with you helps the world") are a disincentive from getting into that profession.

All that said, I suspect that a purely free-market healthcare system would be worse for the very poor than a socialist one like England (unless the culture had a particularly enthusiastic charitable ethic. Maybe that would develop? Does government charity crowd out private charity?).

Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by davidw on Wednesday December 31, 2008 @04:45AM (#415341)
One possible solution would be to create a free market system, with some government guarantees for those who are unable to pay themselves. That has some problems of its own, but it at least attempts to capture the good bits of a free market system, while not leaving the poor to die in the gutters. Of course, this is more complex than the comment I originally replied to about "just let some entrepreneur take care of it".
Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by pelle on Tuesday December 30, 2008 @09:16PM (#414984)
In almost all cases profit helps us all. A free exchange benefits all parties. You have something I want, I have something you want.

When this situation gets distorted through monopoly or other forms of regulations it is generally speaking bad for everyone.

Greed is good. My greed is good for you and your greed is good for me. This is the most fundamental philosophy of entrepreneurship albeit said using a word most people through years of indoctrination think is bad.

This is also why I don't like the term social entrepreneurship. Any entrepreneurship that isn't kept a live through some sort of corruption or force is good for society as a whole.

Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by gnaritas on Tuesday December 30, 2008 @09:21PM (#414990)
The world isn't that simple and by the way, monopoly is a natural outcome in a free market system exactly because it doesn't always work. It breaks down, that's why we regulate it. The only place the free market actually works is in libertarians imaginations because they think Atlas Shrugged somehow reflects reality.
Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by pelle on Wednesday December 31, 2008 @03:12AM (#415297)
You do live in a strange world very distant from the one that most of us readers of Hacker News lives in.

Name me one real monopoly that isn't enforced through "social engineering". A free market may have ocasional dominant market leaders like IBM and MS in their time and Google today. None of them are or were monopolies as better technologies and startups will always (lets repeat that word ALWAYS) come around as long as they are allowed.

True monopolies like the telecoms monopolies in many countries are not outcomes of free markets, but rather more or less corrupt deals between governments and a little group of businesses. Most often the monopoly is argued as a way to protect the consumer.

The free market works wonderfully in many different places in the world and in many different aspects of our daily life. Banking, telecoms and health care are not examples of this as they are heavily regulated. Most of us readers of hacker news are doing what we are doing because of the wonders of the free market.

If not we would be marching fists held up high to Washington demanding the creation of the National Department of Internet Services, to give us lifelong employment. Yet we aren't doing that. The free market works great even though our chosen field has been hit by many different bubbles and failures. The market has picked right up with no real government interference (except for financial and gaming fields) and will continue to improve.

Spare me the old marxist marching chants (I should know what they sound like as I used to be one).

Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by gnaritas on Wednesday December 31, 2008 @12:59PM (#415703)
No, I live in the real world where unrestrained free trade is bad because people seeking profit are not inherently good when they acquire too much power. See Standard Oil, John D. Rockefeller and some history about why we started trust busting in the first place.

Your view that the free market works wonderfully if left alone is simply naive. The real world is simply more complex than that.

In fact, your belief that there even is such a thing as a free market is naive and ignores the very real fact that corruption is inevitable and businesses seek out regulation to protect themselves from competitors destroying the very free market they so claim to love. Any truly free market is simply a temporary state of existence destined to die as soon as corruption takes hold, which it always does.

Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by pelle on Thursday January 01, 2009 @10:16PM (#416974)
You yourself just answered why regulation can't ever work correctly: "The real world is simply more complex than that."

As a programmer you should know that extremely complex systems like the world can not ever be managed by a small group of super clever beings.

This has been the fallacy of each and every of "I'm smart you're not, I'll run things" philosophies originally invented by Plato and perfected by Marx.

The world is a complex system managed by 6 billion autonomous beings. Together these 6 billion autonomous beings for an extremely smart mega intelligence. While you, I and our "leaders" may be smarter than the vast majority of these individuals. Together though is another story.

I agree with your point about corruption as long as we assume the presence of a regulating entity. Corruption is essentially the markets way of calculating a price on overcoming social engineering.

But without regulators in the first place it would not exist and would simply be just other transaction between two or more parties.

Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by JeffL on Wednesday December 31, 2008 @03:02AM (#415288)
I wish I could upvote this comment more than once -- I think it is dead on.

Profit is the creation of value. If there's no profit, then there's no value added.

Profit works great for food, shelter, clothes, heat, and most every basic human need.

I think what really messes up the healthcare market is that the more that technology progresses, the more sophisticated and expensive treatments we discover. The cost and effectiveness of treatments are both soaring, yet people whose means are not rising as fast feel entitled to the best health care no matter what. I think as technology advances, things will only get more distorted until we realize that everyone should only get what they pay for (or what their insurance that is correctly priced by the market will cover and pay for.)

Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by chollida1 on Wednesday December 31, 2008 @12:10PM (#415648)
> Profit is the creation of value. If there's no profit, then there's no value added.

I hope you mean profit in the non monetary sense then. ie profit meaning to increase someones standard of living?

Charitable workers don't make any money and I'd say they add alot of value to other peoples lives.

Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by pelle on Tuesday December 30, 2008 @09:08PM (#414976)
Health is no different than other services in 99.9% of the cases. We should not optimize the entire system for that 0.1% of cases. The market optimizes everything for the better if it is allowed.

For the exceptions, use exception handling also known as charities such as non profit hospitals and health centers who already donate health care to the poor.

The increased efficiency and lower cost of a non regulated approach would benefit all and make it easier and cheaper to provide good care to everyone.

Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by gnaritas on Tuesday December 30, 2008 @09:17PM (#414987)
> The market optimizes everything for the better if it is allowed.

Baloney. This is a belief, not a fact.

Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by pelle on Wednesday December 31, 2008 @02:57AM (#415285)
It is a fact that any transaction between two people that is not distorted in any way by outside parties will leave both parties better off.
Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by gnaritas on Wednesday December 31, 2008 @12:21PM (#415663)
No, it isn't. You're making the huge assumption that both parties are equal in the exchange and one party isn't using force on the other. Again, typical libertarian fantasy assumes everyone is nice, wake up, they aren't.
Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by dk on Wednesday December 31, 2008 @02:46PM (#415811)
It doesn't require anything you name here except the absence of force. No libertarian thinks or assumes everyone must be nice and no libertarian thinker has ever predicated his argument on such.

You know, there actually have been some highly intelligent and thoughtful libertarian thinkers, far from whatever fantasy you may have.

Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by sfk on Wednesday December 31, 2008 @05:00AM (#415344)
> The market optimizes everything for the better if it is allowed.

Such as financial products? I think we have enough evidence right now that people are not mature enough for a totally free market.

Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by pelle on Wednesday December 31, 2008 @05:15AM (#415349)
You are talking about one of the most highly regulated markets in the US. It's been at least 100 years since the financial markets where free in the US.
Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by jbjohns on Wednesday December 31, 2008 @08:29AM (#415420)
You do realize that this whole thing came crashing down because of the very lightly (if any) regulated CDO's right?
Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by byrneseyeview on Wednesday December 31, 2008 @09:27AM (#415466)
You don't think the mortgage market had anything to do with it? As far as I know, the problem is not that CDOs trade at a discount to their underlying value; it's that the underlying value has dropped.
Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by jbjohns on Wednesday December 31, 2008 @09:35AM (#415479)
Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by byrneseyeview on Wednesday December 31, 2008 @09:49AM (#415494)
I am pretty sure that was implicit in my comment. I have read the Lewis piece, which is a great way to get an overview from the perspective of the half-dozen folks willing to give Lewis an interview. I'm not saying that this was entirely due to government intervention -- just that the giant tax incentives, aggressive government market manipulation, and $100B+ portfolios long mortgages and short puts created by government agencies.
Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by jmtulloss on Tuesday December 30, 2008 @07:02PM (#414862)
I agree with you, but it's not that black and white. Insurance companies are usually the ones paying, not the individual. As such, they have a lot of control over the price (especially in the case of medicare). While it might be life or death for the individual, it's not for the insurance company.
Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by gnaritas on Tuesday December 30, 2008 @09:13PM (#414978)
Which is a big part of the problem, we've put an entity between doctor and patient who's motive is profit rather than helping the patient. Insurance companies figured out a long time ago that the best way to profit was to deny claims and avoid paying in any way they can.

An entire sub-industry has popped up around coding claims correctly because doctors have figured out what they can and can't get paid for, the effect being the insurance companies now basically dictate treatments rather than the doctor. Frankly it's extremely fucked up and it's caused entirely by companies seeing the most profit.

Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by jmtulloss on Wednesday December 31, 2008 @12:09AM (#415154)
Can't argue with that.