Any mechanism that could make the human mind non-algorithmic (none have been discovered so far) could still be harnesses by synthetic life forms. Penrose's non-algorithmic mind idea has far fewer ethical or religious implications than a lot of people seem to think. In his world thinking machines are still possible, the only trick is that Turing machines can't do it.
Personally, I don't think that there is a special mechanism (or pixie-dust) that separates my brain function from that of my cat. Of course, there are some qualitative differences which I clearly don't understand. But, blaming the fact that I don't understand the differences on the lack of some scientific breakthrough doesn't seem to clear the whole problem up : It's passing the buck.
IMHO, when the 'trick' to consciousness is found, people will look back and see that what seemed like pixie-dust was just a change in Order() of the system as a brain gets more complex. And there's nothing to suggest that there couldn't be another similar 'upshift' in consciousness beyond that which regulation-sized human brains can do...
If there is an unknown process in reality that does this then why can't a computer be designed to take advantage of this once we know that. The burden of proof is on you to prove the process not hand wave it away.