Re:California companies wrote their own gig worker law. Now ...
by mullingitover on Wednesday September 04, 2024 @08:35PM
(#41452318)
It's sort of elitist to essentially say, "There was a well funded campaign for a ballot measure, and voters are too hopelessly stupid to see past it and make their own decisions." I voted for it because I thought AB4 was a badly written law and the legislature needed to be chastised. I'd vote for it again. As another commenter pointed out here, AB4 was a mess that threatened to disrupt a large number of people's livelihoods.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:California companies wrote their own gig worker law. Now ...
by csb6 on Wednesday September 04, 2024 @09:43PM
(#41452702)
Is it elitist to say that marketing works, even if it ultimately is not in the target audience’s self-interest? Being under-informed or given misleading information is not the same as being stupid.
Re:California companies wrote their own gig worker law. Now ...
by mullingitover on Wednesday September 04, 2024 @10:21PM
(#41452899)
> Is it elitist to say that marketing works, even if it ultimately is not in the target audience’s self-interest?
Is it elitism to tell someone they don't know their own self-interest, and you do?
Re:California companies wrote their own gig worker law. Now ...
by csb6 on Wednesday September 04, 2024 @11:42PM
(#41453258)
With that attitude, no policy would ever need to be advocated for, and there would be no reason to buy campaign ads. Marketing as a business would be completely useless.
The rideshare companies clearly don’t share your philosophy - otherwise they would not have spent massive amounts of money promoting the proposition. It seems reasonable to me that they were trying to sell a piece of legislation to voters that would greatly benefit the rideshare companies financially while downplaying the negative effects many believed it would have on gig workers.
Re:California companies wrote their own gig worker law. Now ...
by Larrikin on Wednesday September 04, 2024 @10:24PM
(#41452912)
Is it elitism to refuse to answer a question and instead ask another question?
Re:California companies wrote their own gig worker law. Now ...
by pdoege on Wednesday September 04, 2024 @08:43PM
(#41452356)
Did you miss quote the OP?
Re:California companies wrote their own gig worker law. Now ...
by mullingitover on Wednesday September 04, 2024 @08:59PM
(#41452451)
Not quoting OP directly, just commenting on the oft-used trope ('the votes were bought!') used to attack the measure's legitimacy.
Re:California companies wrote their own gig worker law. Now ...
by carapace on Wednesday September 04, 2024 @09:29PM
(#41452621)
Why do you think they spent $200M?
Re:California companies wrote their own gig worker law. Now ...
by JKCalhoun on Wednesday September 04, 2024 @09:52PM
(#41452744)
Good point. Whether $200M bought any votes, it's telling that corporate CA thought it was worth that.
Re:California companies wrote their own gig worker law. Now ...
by snapcaster on Thursday September 05, 2024 @08:10AM
(#41455815)
Can you explain why that isn't a good point? I assume companies don't spend $200 million for something that won't be in their benefit