News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by mdasen on Tuesday December 30, 2008 @01:21PM (#414479)
As someone in Boston, I can tell you that rent control was terrible here. The rent controlled units went to people with high incomes and political power (including mayors and those sitting on the Supreme Judicial Court). Most rent controlled units were simply taken off the market in one way or another. If you're getting well below market rent, you tend to look for other ways to use the property and some just allowed relatives or friends to use it rather than bothering with renting, but a lot converted them into condos. The effect was the same - people had to move.

Even the Boston Phoenix (the leftist alternative paper akin to New York's Village Voice) came out against it.

The fact is that when you put price controls in place, who gets something is determined by factors other than what you're willing to pay for it. In housing, that means:

1. Will you bribe people? Will you bribe the landlord renting the apartment with, say, an extra $200 per month? Will you bribe the current resident of the apartment with $2,000 to vacate and give it to you all the time claiming to the landlord that they haven't left?

2. Are you willing to live in a slum? Landlords don't improve properties when they can't charge more for those improvements. Unsanitary conditions? Screw you! They can rent it to plenty of other people willing to live in that squalor. Properties just deteriorate until they are uninhabitable (or barely habitable) and it removes more properties from the market. With tenancy at will, landlords are able to evict anyone without reason with 30 days notice. Should you complain, you're out and unlikely to find another place.

3. Will you even be able to find a place? No one is willing to move because they won't be able to find another place. People hang on for dear life.

Price caps create shortages. The remaining people get to fight like shoppers at a Best Buy at Christmas for one of those Nintendo Wiis.

The first thing to go is anyone renting a room in their house because, for the limited rent they could get, they could use it better for themselves as a guest room or something. Next is anything that can be converted to condos. Remaining rental places are kept abysmally and many eventually become uninhabitable. Any little brightness in this situation is hoarded by a lucky few who tend to be those with political or economic power (doctors, lawyers, mayors, and judges) and you can't even pry those places from their cold dead hands.

Economics finds an interesting balance a lot of the time. If you force landlords to rent for pennies, they don't maintain their property until it's in a state that wouldn't command more than pennies in rent. If you are forcing tenants to not pay more than $x in rent per month, they'll give under the table for anyplace that's nice.

The easiest way to drive down housing prices is to increase the amount of housing. Landlords don't want vacancies and lower their prices to fill. The problem is that, in some cities, there are more people who want to live in them than there are housing units available. So, prices rise until some of those people decide they'd rather spend less and live in a less desirable area.

Other than price, what else should determine who gets in and who doesn't?

Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by loumf on Tuesday December 30, 2008 @03:12PM (#414595)
Aside from anecdotes, do you have access to any data that substantiates the claim that "The rent controlled units went to people with high incomes and political power" -- can you put a figure on it (50%, 60%, higher?).

My grandparents lived in rent controlled apartments in NYC that they could not have afforded to stay in -- moved there in the 30's in neighborhoods that filled with gang violence -- but gentrified around them and became very expensive. There are anecdotes both ways.

Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by mhartl on Tuesday December 30, 2008 @04:36PM (#414707)
My grandparents lived in rent controlled apartments in NYC that they could not have afforded to stay in

This is selection bias. Suppose the government raised the federal minimum wage to $50/hr. This would cause massive unemployment (and, no doubt, a thriving black market for labor), but some lucky low-income workers would keep their jobs. You could then point to one of those workers and say, "Hey, I know someone who has a high-paying job that wouldn't exist but for the new minimum wage." But this ignores the damage done to everyone else through unemployment and higher prices. And so it goes with your lucky grandparents.

You can avoid these sorts of errors by consistent application of the following rule:

The art of economics consists in looking not merely at the immediate but at the longer effects of any act or policy; it consists in tracing the consequences of that policy not merely for one group but for all groups.

-- Henry Hazlitt, Economics in One Lesson http://jim.com/econ/contents.html

Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by loumf on Tuesday December 30, 2008 @09:22PM (#414991)
I gave a counter-example to show how ridiculous it is to talk about this through anecdotes. Yes, it's selection bias -- the entire top-rated comment on this thread is full of anecdotes are data arguments. Thanks for the pointers on avoiding this error in the future -- sheesh.
Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by calambrac on Tuesday December 30, 2008 @05:05PM (#414740)
Okay, fine, but the op that he's replying to suffered the same flaw by pointing to cases of politically connected wealthy people in rent-controlled apartments. Where's the proof that rent-control inflicts large systemic damage across all groups? It's certainly not in the topic's article (see my other post).
Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by timr on Tuesday December 30, 2008 @03:33PM (#414630)
Indeed. I live in a rent-controlled apartment in San Francisco, and it is not squalid, the landlord is not crooked, and neither I, nor the other tenants, are politically powerful.

I heard a lot of horror stories about rent control before I moved here, but so far the stories haven't approximated the reality. Perhaps the problem lies the details of the rent control policies in question, and not with the concept of rent control itself.

Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by toby on Tuesday December 30, 2008 @06:07PM (#414811)
I also live in a rent-controlled apartment in SF. I'm not sure what the particular policy in Boston is, but here they can increase the rent by 3%/year (I think) while I live there. After I leave, they can reset it to whatever they like.

So, in principle, if market rents increase a lot, the landlord has an incentive for me to leave. I think there's another side to this though: I've been a great tenant for a while and always pay on time -- if I leave, he runs the risk of getting a scammer who just won't pay and will take a year to evict.

Also, since I've locked in a nice rate, I have an incentive to stay and even make minor improvements (like clearing all the dead growth from the patio, etc.)

I think rent control probably is not a great idea in many places, but in SF it seems to work. My pet theory is that the boom-bust cycle here is much more severe and without rent control the city would have no stable population.

Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by jmtulloss on Tuesday December 30, 2008 @07:08PM (#414871)
The question for both of you is how did you get the rent controlled apartment? I bet it wasn't through craigslist. Everybody I know in the city who lives under rent control (which, admittedly, is not very many) found their places through friends.

Not that it's a bad thing, but it supports the idea that you have to be "connected" to get a place. Maybe not a lawyer or a judge, but having been around the city helps.

Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by toby on Tuesday December 30, 2008 @08:01PM (#414922)
It was through Craigslist... the deal is that every building in San Francisco built before a certain year (I don't remember which year) is rent controlled, so you don't really need a connection. The year cutoff is, I assume, to encourage developers to build new rental properties.

There was a proposition to ban rent control in California, which failed to pass.

Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by jmtulloss on Wednesday December 31, 2008 @12:05AM (#415149)
Interesting. I've had trouble finding a rent controlled apartment through craigslist. I'll have to look harder in the future.
Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by ojbyrne on Tuesday December 30, 2008 @08:00PM (#414920)
I lived in a rent-controlled apt in SF that I found through craiglist. It wasn't cheap, nor squalid - Similar to what the other people say. My experiences over 20 years of renting also say - landlords treat good tenants like gold - if you don't make noise, don't sell drugs, and pay on time, they generally are happy to not raise your rent.
Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by timr on Tuesday December 30, 2008 @07:36PM (#414901)
I got mine through craigslist. So did the other people I know who live in rent-controlled places.
Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by JabavuAdams on Tuesday December 30, 2008 @08:37PM (#414950)
> My grandparents lived in rent controlled apartments in NYC that they could not have afforded to stay in [...]

This is how rent-control can create shortages.

Under rent-control, older people who would otherwise downsize have no incentive to do so. Younger people who might still be able to live with their parents instead rent separate apartments.

The fundamental problem is there's not enough housing for everyone to get as much of it as they want. So, there's a need to economize.

The additional problem is that your residence is not a commodity to you. Being forced, by the market, to move out of your place is very traumatic, even if it could be better used by someone else.

Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by loumf on Tuesday December 30, 2008 @10:32PM (#415062)
The point of the anecdote was to show how anecdotes aren't a good way to argue. The anecdote doesn't show anything -- not my point, and not yours either.

Their specific story is not the point -- my point was that if you want to cherry-pick anecdotes of a program not working, one can always counter-argue with other anecdotes.

Either you believe that it is in the public interest to have some availability of low-income housing or you don't. I do think it's in my interest and I accept that I will pay more to have it be available.

Is rent-control the best way to achieve that goal -- I don't know -- this isn't an area of my expertise (judging from this thread, it isn't any HNer's) -- I haven't heard anyone propose something better -- just complain about it based on hearsay.

Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by JabavuAdams on Wednesday December 31, 2008 @01:20PM (#415727)
> Is rent-control the best way to achieve that goal -- I don't know -- [...] -- I haven't heard anyone propose something better -- just complain about it based on hearsay.

What if rent control is actually causing shortages were there's no physical scarcity? We can mostly agree on intent, but sometimes, collectively, we enact plans that cause the opposite of what we want.

It happens that I'm just reading Thomas Sowell's Basic Economics. In the chapter on price controls, he argues that rent control (and price controls, in general) cause shortages where there is no scarcity of the underlying commodity.

As you point out, I'm not an expert, and FWIW I haven't read the original sources. I have some problems with his analysis of medical care price controls, but I'll get to that later.

Here are some quotes and his cites...

All the quotes are from:

Sowell, T. (2007). Basic Economics. A Common Sense Guide to the Economy. 3rd ed. New York: Basic Books.

"Before rent control was imposed in Sweden, less than one-fourth of all unmarried adults there lived in their own separate housing units in 1940, but that proportion rose over the years until just over half did by 1975." (p.41)

... from the article, "The Rise, Fall and Revival of Swedish Rent Control", in the book Roofs or Ceilings? by Milton Friedman and George Stigler.

"In San Francisco, a study in 2001 showed that 49 percent of that city's rent-controlled apartments had only a single occupant, while a severe housing shortage in the city had thousands of people living considerable distances away and making long commutes to their jobs in San Francisco." (p.41)

... from p.21 of San Francisco Housing DataBook, commissioned by the city, and produced by consultants Bay Area Economics, in 2001.

"Meanwhile, a Census report showed likewise that 48 percent of all households in Manhattan, where most apartments are under some form of rent control, are occupied by only one person." (p.41)

... from page A2 of the September 3, 2005 issue of the San Francisco Chronicle, title: "Census: More Americans Living Alone."

"A study published in 2001 showed that more than one-fourth of the occupants of rent-controlled apartments in San Francisco had household incomes of more than $100,000 a year." (p.48)

... not sure where he got this -- I need to get back to coding -- if you care, check out his Sources chapter.

Without looking further into the issue, I'm reasonably convinced that rent control drives up rental prices, and creates housing shortages (at the artificially low price levels).

BUT ...

What this doesn't consider is that my home is not a fungible or liquid asset for most people. You may be able to change residences easily, but it will take time for your new residence to become your home.

It's a lot easier to consume a bit less power, produce a bit less garbage, or spend a little less money in response to changing market conditions.

Because of this, people feel very strongly about holding on to their homes, even if by this hoarding, they're harming others.

Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by calambrac on Tuesday December 30, 2008 @03:13PM (#414599)
Here's the Phoenix coming out against rent control: http://thebostonphoenix.com/boston/news_features/editorial/d...

It's not at all an endorsement of the naked free market like Cato would want to see.

Re:How Rent Control Drives Out Affordable Housing by michaelneale on Tuesday December 30, 2008 @08:39PM (#414953)
I have never lived anywhere to see rent control in action, but its an interesting demonstration of economics when you fix one variable.

Also - how to doctors have political or economic power? (do you mean they earn enough to bribe?)