News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Owners of 1-Time Passcode Theft Service Plead Guilty by bn-l on Monday September 02, 2024 @03:02PM (#41427952)
I think it's security by popularity: You can't be blamed if it's "industry standard". Meanwhile it's 10x less hassle than trying to get people to use an authenticator. Passkeys aren't perfect privacy wise (and everything google touches is suspect), but they are easy.
Re:Owners of 1-Time Passcode Theft Service Plead Guilty by chrisweekly on Monday September 02, 2024 @05:09PM (#41428844)
> "You can't be blamed if it's "industry standard".

Thankfully, that's not true. Class action lawsuits can and do successfully target widespread industry malpractice. My first job out of college was as a paralegal, helping over 90 million American plaintiffs sue nearly every major life insurance company in the country for the previously common "standard behavior" of insurance agents convincing policyholders to periodically "roll over" their accounts, to the sole benefit of the agents and their employers. The settlement payout for each participant was typically meager -- but the malpractice was stopped.

Re:Owners of 1-Time Passcode Theft Service Plead Guilty by jollyllama on Tuesday September 03, 2024 @08:12AM (#41434147)
>Thankfully, that's not true.

We'll see how much Crowdstrike pays out.

Re:Owners of 1-Time Passcode Theft Service Plead Guilty by pixl97 on Tuesday September 03, 2024 @12:00PM (#41436237)
Directly or indirectly?
Re:Owners of 1-Time Passcode Theft Service Plead Guilty by miki123211 on Monday September 02, 2024 @05:40PM (#41429021)
Not only that, but mandatory authenticators would also create a support (and security) nightmare the moment you stepped out of the upper-middle-class, privileged tech worker world.

They work great if you assume that everybody has a smartphone (as opposed to a feature phone), that they don't have their phones stolen every other month, that they know how to set up an authenticator app, that they'll remember to reconfigure everything properly when migrating to a new phone and won't immediately throw the old one away and so on.

This problem is made even worse by the notoriously bad UX of most authenticator apps, notably the lack of automatic iCloud / Google Drive backup functionality and their inability to automatically show the code on screen whenever it's needed.

The nice thing about SMS is that you can outsource most of the support burden to carriers, which have to handle it anyway. Carriers have the advantage that they usually speak the user's language, have an office relatively nearby, and can verify your government ID in person if need be.

Re:Owners of 1-Time Passcode Theft Service Plead Guilty by ensignavenger on Tuesday September 03, 2024 @12:04AM (#41431141)
Did the carriers agree to take on this role of securing SMS messages for authentication? If I were a carrier, I would be actively fighting this nonsense.
Re:Owners of 1-Time Passcode Theft Service Plead Guilty by AStonesThrow on Tuesday September 03, 2024 @03:17AM (#41432190)
How secure do they need to be? It's a single ephemeral factor. Every cell tower a numbers station. Sometimes I relay my OTP code to my friends in FB chat if I think the number has cool properties. I don't tell them anything else about the sign-in, so my self-breach has a rather limited risk factor. Didn't that LifeLock guy advertise his SSN everywhere?

I'd say reliability counts for more in these cases, and SMS was designed for unreliability, like UDP. So I'd be more concerned about the relationships and gateways from MFA services to send out their codes, and ensure that they can be received in a timely fashion. This message will self-destruct in ten minutes.

Re:Owners of 1-Time Passcode Theft Service Plead Guilty by miki123211 on Tuesday September 03, 2024 @06:35AM (#41433400)
The carriers basically have to do this anyway, one way or another, because people want to get their phone number back when something bad happens to their phone. This would be true even without SMS authentication.

A part of it is mandated by regulation, most countries require carriers to let their customers port their phone numbers out. When handling those port out requests, they don't necessarily have enough data to decide whether the request is legitimate or not, yet refusing such requests too often would draw the ire of regulators, which is something no carrier wants.

Re:Owners of 1-Time Passcode Theft Service Plead Guilty by teo_zero on Tuesday September 03, 2024 @01:37AM (#41431614)
> They work great if you assume [...] that they'll remember to reconfigure everything properly when migrating to a new phone and won't immediately throw the old one away and so on.

This would be a terrible assumption even for upper-middle-class people!